BBCi CATEGORIES   TV   RADIO   COMMUNICATE   WHERE I LIVE   INDEX    SEARCH 

Commonwealth Games 2002
You are in: Boxing  
Front Page 
Statistics 
Athletics 
Swimming 
Badminton 
Boxing 
Cycling 
Rugby 7's 
Hockey 
Gymnastics 
Squash 
Judo 
Other Sports 
Features 
Sports Talk 
BBC Coverage 
Photo Galleries 
Event Guide 
Venue Guide 
Stars to Watch 
Nations 
Quiz 

Play Denise Lewis Heptathlon BBC Sport

BBC Weather

BBC News

Boxing Wednesday, 31 July, 2002, 12:38 GMT 13:38 UK
Weary judges feeling the strain
Ludumo Galada of South Africa in action at Manchester
The 15-point rule has been particularly contentious

"This is making a mockery of the sport that I love".

Such comments are not unusual at a boxing venue after a perceived dodgy decision.

But one does sit up and take notice when the anger is being directed by someone who is judging at these Commonwealth Games.

Tuesday was a testing day for the referees and judges at Wythenshawe Forum.

Outspoken International Amateur Boxing Association President Anwar Chowdhry was telling anybody prepared to listen that he had suspended Ugandan judge David Agong and another referee for poor performances in a bout on Saturday.

open quote
It's impossible with this computer system to get it right
end quote
Boxing judge

The Pakistani-born president was unhappy with the verdict meted out against his fellow-countryman Asghar Ali Shah after the contest with Scotland's Kevin Anderson.

In all, Dr Chowdry had warned nine officials to buck up their act and summoned referees and judges to a meeting on Thursday ahead of the semi-finals and finals at the 9,500 capacity MEN Arena.

After this most public of rebukes, it was hardly surprisingly that several officials looked a tad weary when they arrived for the evening session.

One referee spoke of his relief that this was his final tournament.

"It's getting crazy. I got a warning earlier this week but it's impossible with this computer system to get it right," he added.

Many felt Jamie Arthur's contest was ended prematurely on Tuesday
Jamie Arthur's contest on Tuesday ended early

Like all the officials, he was speaking "strictly off the record" because after all, there was still the small matter of maybe getting to officiate at one of the big finals in the MEN Arena.

The contentious scoring system awards a point to fighters when three or more of the five judges presses their computer button within one second of each other.

As Tuesday evening wore on and verdicts became ever more baffling, the officials sitting in front of the press bench became even more outspoken.

At least three competitive fights had been ended in ridiculously premature fashion because of the 15-point rule which provides for stoppages because opponents are supposedly being outclassed.

One judge who had angrily directed criticism at the International president's managerial style was jokingly asked by BBC Sport Online whether this would be his last tournament.

"It will be if you print what I just said," he replied.

Ironically, the judges had been welcomed out to the arena with James Brown's I Feel Good, blaring out over the loudspeaker.

Hardly appropriate in the circumstances.


Review the action

Expert verdicts

Manchester features

Have your say

Internet links
Links to more Boxing stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Boxing stories

© BBC ^ Back to top

Front Page | Statistics

Athletics | Swimming | Badminton | Boxing | Cycling
Rugby 7's | Hockey | Gymnastics | Squash | Judo | Other Sports

Features | Sports Talk | BBC Coverage | Photo Galleries

Event Guide | Venue Guide | Stars to Watch | Nations | Quiz