Skip to main content
BBC SPORT / SCOTTISH PREMIER
Graphics Version | BBC News Home
Sport Homepage | Football | World Cup 2010 | Formula 1 | Olympics | Vancouver 2010 | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League | Tennis | Golf | Athletics | Cycling | Motorbikes | Boxing | Snooker | Horse Racing | Disability Sport | Other sport... | Sports Personality | TV/Radio Schedule | Sport Academy | Fun and Games | Inside Sport | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales
Football Contents:  World Cup 2010 | My Club | Gossip | Premier League | Championship | League One | League Two | Non League | FA Cup | League Cup | Scottish Premier | Scottish League | Scottish Cups | Welsh | Irish | Europe | African Women | Football Focus | Match of the Day | Final Score | World Football | Skills | Laws & Equipment | Get Involved | Your Game

Tuesday, 2 October 2007, 08:37 GMT 09:37 UK

Ref Dougal admits penalty error

Referee Stuart Dougal Referee Stuart Dougal has admitted that he made an error in awarding Hibernian a penalty during the Edinburgh side's 4-1 victory over Kilmarnock.

Clayton Donaldson won the first of his two spot kicks on Saturday after a challenge by Frazer Wright.

And, on the Scottish FA's Whistleblower site, Dougal said that, after reviewing television evidence, it should not have been given as a foul.

Television pictures clearly showed that Wright played the ball first.

However, the referee's admission does not affect the yellow card shown to the Kilmarnock defender during the Scottish Premier League game.

"Our angles were such that we were not best placed to see the incident as clearly as was shown on TV"
Stuart Dougal

Dougal said: "I was approaching play from behind and saw Mr Wright slide tackle his opponent.

"From my angle, it appeared as if he had played through the opponent, thus fouling him, to win the ball and I was sure of my thoughts.

"However, after viewing the incident on TV, I can see that Mr Wright played the ball cleanly first just before there was contact with the attacker.

MY SPORT: DEBATE
" Credit has to go to Dougal, who has publicly admitted his mistake "
#46 - Aldo

"People will question why the stand side assistant referee didn't get involved, but he could not see if there had been initial illegal contact.

"We were using radio communication equipment with immediate contact."

The penalty, scored by Donaldson on his way to a hat-trick, was awarded at a time when Hibs were 1-0 ahead.

"Making decisions is mainly down to angles and, on this occasion, while we were both in the recognised positions for this type of move, our angles were such that we were not best placed to see the incident as clearly as was shown on TV," added Dougal.



E-mail this to a friend
Related to this story:

Collins hails goal-hero Donaldson (29 Sep 07 |  Hibernian )
Jefferies admits Hibs merited win (29 Sep 07 |  Kilmarnock )
Hibernian 4-1 Kilmarnock (29 Sep 07 |  Scottish Premier )

RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
BBC Sport club pages
Scottish FA
My Sport
BBC Sport Scotland
Live SPL coverage
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



SEARCH BBC SPORT: 

Sport Homepage | Football | World Cup 2010 | Formula 1 | Olympics | Vancouver 2010 | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League | Tennis | Golf | Athletics | Cycling | Motorbikes | Boxing | Snooker | Horse Racing | Disability Sport | Other sport... | Sports Personality | TV/Radio Schedule | Sport Academy | Fun and Games | Inside Sport | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales
Football Contents:  World Cup 2010 | My Club | Gossip | Premier League | Championship | League One | League Two | Non League | FA Cup | League Cup | Scottish Premier | Scottish League | Scottish Cups | Welsh | Irish | Europe | African Women | Football Focus | Match of the Day | Final Score | World Football | Skills | Laws & Equipment | Get Involved | Your Game

^ Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | Feedback | Help | ©