Skip to main content
BBC SPORT / FOOTBALL
Graphics Version | BBC News Home
Sport Homepage | Football | World Cup 2010 | Formula 1 | Olympics | Vancouver 2010 | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League | Tennis | Golf | Athletics | Cycling | Motorbikes | Boxing | Snooker | Horse Racing | Disability Sport | Other sport... | Sports Personality | TV/Radio Schedule | Sport Academy | Fun and Games | Inside Sport | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales
Football Contents:  World Cup 2010 | My Club | Gossip | Premier League | Championship | League One | League Two | Non League | FA Cup | League Cup | Scottish Premier | Scottish League | Scottish Cups | Welsh | Irish | Europe | African Women | Football Focus | Match of the Day | Final Score | World Football | Skills | Laws & Equipment | Get Involved | Your Game

10:53 GMT, Friday, 26 September 2008 11:53 UK

West Ham suffer Tevez appeal blow

By Simon Austin

Carlos Tevez

West Ham's hopes of avoiding a huge payout in the Carlos Tevez affair have suffered a serious setback.

The Hammers are drafting a "statement of appeal" to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, yet the Lausanne court will not be able to hear the case.

Its secretary general, Matthieu Reeb, told BBC Sport: "As things stand, CAS would not be able to hear this case.

"We would need agreement from Sheffield United and for Football Association rules to allow an appeal to CAS."

Sheffield United are unlikely, to say the least, to give agreement to an appeal that could overturn the decision of the independent tribunal.

And the FA actually has a rule that stipulates there cannot be an appeal from the verdict of an independent tribunal.

"We do not accept that one player's contribution can be placed over that of the team as a whole "
West Ham statement

Rule K5c states that by signing up to arbitration, "the parties shall be deemed to have waived irrevocably any right to appeal, review or any recourse to a court of law".

A West Ham spokesman said the club was currently "drafting a statement of appeal" to CAS.

The independent tribunal, whose verdict has not yet been officially published, ruled that Tevez was not eligible to play at the end of the 2006/07 season and played a key role in West Ham's Premiership survival.

Sheffield United, who were relegated, are claiming more than £30m in compensation from the Hammers.

The tribunal will decide on the amount of compensation to be paid at a further hearing, due to be held early next year.

Earlier this week the Hammers issued a statement saying: "While we respect the judgement of the arbitration panel, we do not accept that one player's contribution can be placed over that of the team as a whole nor used as the basis for judging the results of a 38-game season.

606: DEBATE
What do you make of West Ham's CAS predicament?
"This ruling undermines the significant efforts of our entire playing squad and coaching staff over the duration of the 2006/07 Premier League season and does not take sufficient account of the performances of the other 19 clubs in the competition.

"We acknowledge again that the club broke Premier League rules in the original signing of Carlos Tevez but we were dealt with accordingly by an independent Premier League commission and accepted the significant punishment handed down at that time.

"In light of this and the wider implications of this latest ruling for English football we have decided to ask that the case be considered by the Court of Arbitration for Sport."

West Ham were found guilty last April of acting improperly and withholding vital documentation over the ownership of Argentine duo Tevez and Javier Mascherano, whom they signed in 2006.

A three-man Premier League arbitration panel fined the Hammers £5.5m, but did not dock them points, and they went on to survive the drop on the final day, while Sheffield United were relegated.

Having failed in their attempt to have the original punishment overturned, the Yorkshire club invoked an FA rule that allows clubs with a legal dispute to go before an independent tribunal.



E-mail this to a friend
Related to this story:

Sheff Utd players may sue Hammers (26 Sep 08 |  Football )
Sheff Utd win West Ham tribunal (23 Sep 08 |  Football )
Tevez tribunal decision explained (24 Sep 08 |  Premier League )
Blades set to hear Tevez outcome (10 Jul 08 |  Sheff Utd )
Sheff Utd fight for compensation (07 Nov 07 |  Sheff Utd )
Blades seek Hammers compensation (16 Aug 07 |  Sheff Utd )
Tevez saga prompts rule changes (09 Aug 07 |  Premier League )
Blades lose appeal on relegation (03 Jul 07 |  Premier League )
Sheff Utd lose High Court appeal (13 Jul 07 |  Sheff Utd )
West Ham not to appeal over fine (09 May 07 |  West Ham )
West Ham receive Tevez clearance (28 Apr 07 |  West Ham )
West Ham sign Tevez & Mascherano (31 Aug 06 |  West Ham )
Auletta beats Pound to CAS role (03 Apr 08 |  Sport Homepage )

RELATED INTERNET LINKS:
Blades fans' views on 606
BBC Radio Sheffield audio
Sheffield weather
Sheffield United
West Ham
BBC Sport Championship
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



SEARCH BBC SPORT: 

Sport Homepage | Football | World Cup 2010 | Formula 1 | Olympics | Vancouver 2010 | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League | Tennis | Golf | Athletics | Cycling | Motorbikes | Boxing | Snooker | Horse Racing | Disability Sport | Other sport... | Sports Personality | TV/Radio Schedule | Sport Academy | Fun and Games | Inside Sport | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales
Football Contents:  World Cup 2010 | My Club | Gossip | Premier League | Championship | League One | League Two | Non League | FA Cup | League Cup | Scottish Premier | Scottish League | Scottish Cups | Welsh | Irish | Europe | African Women | Football Focus | Match of the Day | Final Score | World Football | Skills | Laws & Equipment | Get Involved | Your Game

^ Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | Feedback | Help | ©