| You are in: Sports Talk |
![]()
|
Your team of the year
The Professional Footballers' Association selects only two English players in its Premiership team of the year.
Disclaimer: The BBC will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published. The BBC reserves the right to edit comments that are published.
E-mail us with your team of the year.
Ruud van Nistelrooy's 33 goals for Manchester United have seen the Dutchman named as Professional Footballers' Association Players' Player of the Year. Newcastle's Craig Bellamy took the Young Player of the Year award, but only Rio Ferdinand and Wayne Bridge made its Premiership XI. Fulham's Steve Finnan is one of three Irish internationals named in the team, while Arsenal trio Patrick Vieira, Robert Pires and Thierry Henry are all voted in.
Do you agree with the choices? E-mail us with your ultimate Premiership XI.
This team quite simply would beat any team in the world:
1.Dudek, 2.Ashley Cole, 3.Hyypia, 4.Campbell, 5.Beckham, 6.Giggs, 7.Keane, 8.Pires, 9.Van Nistelrooy, 10.Henry, 11.Hasselbaink.
Doesn't Alan Shearer deserve a place as the leading English goal-scorer in the Premiership this season? That's despite missing several weeks through injury.
My Premier 11 would be:
Anelka may not have many goals, but his work rate is unbelievable. Quite frankly, Andy Cole scored 30 a season with Man Utd, as many strikers can with Becks and Giggs creating.
So Nistelrooy, as good as he may be, doesn't get in. Dudek is one of the best in the world, and Hyypia and Desailly are untouchable.
Jerzy Dudek; Lauren, Gareth Southgate, Sol Campbell, Ashley Cole; Freddie Ljungberg, Patrick Vieira, Robert Pires, Laurent Robert; Jimmy Hasselbaink, Thierry Henry
The Players' vote seems pretty fair, and there are only a few changes I'd make: Dudek instead of Given, Mills instead of Finnan and Riise instead of Bridge. It is also close between Henry and Hasselbaink, as both have been outstanding. But Henry gets the nod for the number of chances he has created for others in addition to his own goals.
The lack of English players is a worry, but most of the top English players have missed a lot of games through injury or suffered a lack of form at times.
The PFA have again got it wrong with the selections in key areas. Here are my best players this year (if they were picked in their correct positions): GK Cudicini; LB Riise, CB Terry, CB Hyypia, RB Stockdale; LM Pires, CM Vieira, CM Malbranque, RM Solano; STR Henry, STR Van Nistelrooy.
1. Cudicini (Chelsea)
My team would be: Cudicini; Weir, Ferdinand, Riggot, Riise; Beckham (for his England exploits alone), Hamman, Gerrard, Pires; Hasselbaink and Henry. I can't see how Danny Mills get in the Leeds team, let the alone PFA and England sides.
Dudek;
Finnan,
Hyypia,
Ferdinand,
Bridge;
Giggs,
Keane,
Vieira,
Pires;
Hasselbaink,
Van Nistelrooy.
Cudicini; Bridge, Carragher, Southgate; Beckham, Pires, Ljunberg, Keane; Hasselbaink, Van Nistelrooy.
I think that Pires deserved the award more than Van the Man though.
My team of the year would be:
Dudek; Bridge, Hyypia, Gallas, Carragher; Giggs, Murphy, Keane, Pires; Hasslebank and Van Nistelrooy
The Premiership XI would have to be:
What a joke - Pires is the best player in the league by a long way. Anyone can score goals if they have Beckham and Scholes with them. Solskjaer is a better finisher than Nistelrooy The team is quite reflective of the Premiership's leading players, but I'd have either Cudicini or Dudek in goal. Also, it's good to see Beckham is not included as his name usually gets a mention without any thought. The team is a bit unbalanced with two left wingers, but Pires would be expected to play the right if this was an actual team as he's more versatile than the one-foot wonder from Man Utd.
Pires was robbed of PFA Player of the Year, I hope he gets the Football Writers Prize as that's more esteemed. Although Van Nistelrooy has been superb, the award should have gone to the mercurial Robert Pires. Is there some law that prevents non-Man Utd players from picking up the award? Last year it was Sheringham, and before that Keane who somehow got the award ahead of Phillips, who was the top scorer in Europe!
My Premiership XI is: Cudicini; Harte, Hyypia, Campbell, Finnan; Pires, Vieira, Robert, Duff; Hasselbaink and Van Nistelrooy
I can't see how you could possibly get any better than the following starting XI:
Dudek;
Riise,
Hyypia,
Terry,
Silvestre;
Robert,
Vieira,
Beckham,
Pires;
Henry,
Van Nistelrooy.
As an Arsenal fan I am disappointed that Henry or Pires did not get the award, but I cannot deny the quality of the United striker. Henry is a better all round footballer between goals scored and assists - Ruud doesn't even make it onto the official list of assists - but the Dutchman is a lethal finisher. If he could get into the positions Henry does then he would be close to 40 goals. Fair play to him after his cruciate knee injury, hopefully Pires can recover just as well.
Hopefully this will be the only piece of domestic silverware going to Old Trafford this season!
Van der Sar; Riise, Hyypia, Ferdinand, Carragher; Beckham, Keane, Pires, Giggs; Van Nistelrooy and Henry. That wouldn't be a bad team!
Cudicini; Carragher, Hyypia, Campbell, Bridge; Pires, Vieira, Keane, Giggs; Henry and Hasselbaink. SUBS: Seaman, Ferdinand, Beckham, Gerrard, Van Nistelrooy
Premiership XI: Dudek;
Bridge,
Southgate,
Hyypia,
G. Neville;
Beckham,
Keane,
Giggs,
Pires;
Van Nistelrooy,
and Hasslebaink
Dudek;
Finnan,
Ferdinand,
Hyypia,
Rise;
Beckham,
Gerrard,
Viera,
Pires;
Van Nistelrooy and
Henry.
Subs: Owen, Carragher, Given, Ljungberg, Henchoz
My Premirship XI: Jerzy Dudek; Gary Neville, Sami Hyypia, Stephan Henchoz, Wayne Bridge; Robert Pires, Roy Keane, Patrick Vieira, David Beckham; Ruud Van Nistrlrooy, Jimmy Floyd Hasslebank.
My Premiership XI would have to be:
I'd say: Dudek; Silvestre, Hyypia, Ferdinand, Bridge; Pires, Keane, Beckham, Vieira; Van Nistelrooy, Henry.
I cannot understand how JFH and Marcel Desailly did not make the Premiership XI. Rio is a good player but he is not in Marcel's class yet!
Cudicini;
Lauren,
Ferdinand,
Hyypia,
Riise;
Pires,
Vieira,
Bowyer,
Le Saux;
Viduka,
Van Nistelrooy.
My team of the year is: goalkeeper: Dean Kiely. Defenders: Wayne Bridge, Sami Hyypia, Sol Campbell, Gary Neville. Midfielders: Steven Gerrard, David Beckham, Roy Keane, Robert Pires. Strikers: Ruud Van Nistelrooy, Thierry Henry
If I had to pick a couple of players who came close, then Dennis Bergkamp, Scott Parker and Steve Finnan would be on the verge.
Dudek; Hyypia, Ferdinand, Bridge, Mills; Keane, Beckham, Pires, Anderton; Henry and Van Nistelrooy. Patrick Vieira has not played as well in the first half of the season as he should have done - with Sloppy passing and a lack of aggression. Jerzy Dudek has easily been the best keeper and Beckham has played equally as well as any midfielder.
GK - Given
|
Other top Sports Talk stories:
Links to more Sports Talk stories are at the foot of the page.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Links to more Sports Talk stories
|
| ^^ Back to top | ||
|
Front Page
|
Football
|
Cricket
|
Rugby Union
|
Rugby League
|
Tennis
|
Golf | Motorsport | Boxing | Athletics | Other Sports | Sports Talk | In Depth | Photo Galleries | TV & Radio | BBC Pundits | Question of Sport | Funny Old Game ------------------------------------------------------------ BBC News >> | BBC Weather >> -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- © MMII | News Sources | Privacy |
||