BBC Sport rugbyunion


Related BBC sites

Page last updated at 16:15 GMT, Saturday, 14 November 2009

England 16-9 Argentina

England (9) 16
Try: Banahan Con: Wilkinson Pens: Wilkinson 2 Drop-goal: Wilkinson
Argentina (9) 9
Pens: Rodriguez 3

England celebrate Matt Banahan's try

Video - Banahan try lifts England

By Phil Harlow

England needed a late try from Matt Banahan to beat a dogged Argentina and prevent a sluggish autumn campaign from unravelling at Twickenham.

An error-strewn display was lacking in ingenuity and invention but Martin Johnson's side escaped with a victory.

Jonny Wilkinson's boot allowed England to go to the break at 9-9, with Martin Rodriguez replying for the Pumas.

A tense second half was scoreless until Banahan's 69th-minute try gave England a win they scarcely deserved.

And with New Zealand the next visitors to Twickenham, England can take little comfort from another dismal display.

We have to find a way to improve - Johnson

England, wearing their new purple second kit, went into the match as the eighth best team in the world - two places behind Argentina - and even that ranking looked generous after a match in which they struggled to show any signs of progress from last week's defeat by Australia.

Once again, they seemed to prefer to kick rather than run with the ball, while Ugo Monye, playing out of position at full-back, looked like a fish out of water until switched to the wing.

The 78,743 fans who turned up to Twickenham on a wet and blustery day were treated to a prolonged spell of kick tennis early on before the energetic Lewis Moody - one of the few England players who can be proud of his display - managed to charge down Santiago Fernandez's clearance.

Argentina's Rodrigo Roncero drives forward
Rodrigo Roncero surges forward for Argentina as they seek a try

From the resulting possession, Wilkinson kicked a fine drop-goal, just as he did last week against Australia, to put England into the lead.

Soon after, England were almost over for their first try of the autumn after Juan Fernandez-Lobbe spilled a kick over the top straight into Mark Cueto's path but the winger was unable to finish the chance, thanks to a great tackle from full-back Horacio Agulla.

Fernandez narrowly missed with a drop-goal attempt of his own but Wilkinson put the 22 drop-out straight into touch to hand the initiative back to Argentina and their scrum eventually won the chance for Rodriguez to level the scores with a penalty.

Rodriguez missed from distance after James Haskell conceded a silly penalty at the ruck before Wilkinson's long-range penalty edged England ahead again.

Moody unimpressed by England win

A Monye mistake - one of many on a day to forget from the Harlequins winger - under the high ball led to Haskell conceding another penalty for being offside - and this time Rodriguez made no mistake with the boot.

An ironic cheer rang out from the Twickenham stands when Monye finally took a kick on the full, this time from a missed Fernandez drop-goal, while boos were heard soon after when Shane Geraghty kicked out on the full.

Another missed penalty from Rodriguez let England off the hook after Tom Croft was penalised for holding on as a move lacking any dynamism whatsoever petered out.

Haskell and Monye both knocked-on in quick succession, while Wilkinson's poor form kicking from hand continued. Yet another penalty conceded at the scrum resulted in Rodriguez kicking Argentina 9-6 ahead but Wilkinson levelled late in the half.


England took the inevitable step of moving Monye from full-back to the wing for the second half and England made a dynamic - at least compared to the first half - start.

But a missed Wilkinson penalty was soon followed by a Dylan Hartley knock-on, after a poor Haskell pass, as the mistakes piled up for England.

As predicted, Argentina's scrum was massively superior to England's and the Pumas' dominance gave Rodriguez another chance to kick his side ahead but he squeezed his effort wide.

A decent Cueto run finally gave Twickenham something to shout about but it was a rare spark of life in a display that will give attack coach Brian Smith sleepless nights.

The ball travelled down the England line to Dan Hipkiss and the centre - getting man and ball - passed outside to 20 yards of clear space, with Monye nowhere to be seen.

Matt Banahan
Matt Banahan receives the congratulations of his team-mates

Two more Wilkinson misses added to the feeling that this Test was going the same way as the famous defeat at Twickenham during the Andy Robinson era.

But an attack sparked by Haskell's powerful run led to the ball moving through the hands of Steve Borthwick, Hartley, Hipkiss and Geraghty to allow Banahan to cross and run under the posts.

The sense of relief was palpable but Argentina ensured the nerves would last right until the final whistle as they set up camp in England's 22.

But they could not quite find the breakthrough against England's defence to give themselves the chance of a draw that would have been the least they deserved.

And injuries cannot be much of an excuse for England, with the likes of Felipe Contepomi and Juan Martin Hernandez missing for an Argentina side containing four amateur players.

England: Monye, Cueto, Hipkiss, Geraghty, Banahan, Wilkinson, Hodgson, Payne, Hartley, Bell, Deacon, Borthwick, Croft, Moody, Haskell.
Replacements: Goode for Wilkinson (75), Care for Hodgson (75), Doran-Jones for Payne (63), Thompson for Hartley (69), Worsley for Croft (63).
Not Used: Lawes, Erinle.

Argentina: Agulla, Borges, Tiesi, Rodriguez, Comuzzi, Fernandez, Lalanne, Roncero, Ledesma, Scelzo, Lozada, Albacete, Leonardi, Abadie, Fernandez Lobbe.
Replacements: Figuerola for Lalanne (75), Ayerza for Scelzo (67), Carizza for Lozada (56), Campos for Abadie (34).
Not Used: Basualdo, Urdapilleta, Aramburu.

Att: 78,743

Ref: Nigel Owen (WRFU).

Print Sponsor

see also
Johnson losing patience with team
14 Nov 09 |  English
Autumn internationals as they happened
14 Nov 09 |  Rugby Union
Autumn international photos
14 Nov 09 |  Rugby Union
England change four for Argentina
11 Nov 09 |  English
Lobbe to lead new-look Argentina
11 Nov 09 |  Rugby Union
Flood on verge of Tigers return
11 Nov 09 |  Leicester
Doran-Jones called up by England
09 Nov 09 |  English
Dallaglio wants new-look England
08 Nov 09 |  English
We will learn from loss - Johnson
07 Nov 09 |  Rugby Union
England 9-18 Australia
07 Nov 09 |  Rugby Union

related bbc links:

related internet links:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites