Skip to main contentAccess keys helpA-Z index

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
watch listen BBC Sport BBC Sport
Low graphics|Help
Last Updated: Sunday, 10 September 2006, 13:52 GMT 14:52 UK
Schumacher's tainted legacy

By Andrew Benson
Motorsport editor

Michael Schumacher will head into retirement at the end of this season as the most successful Grand Prix driver of all time, but whether he will be regarded as the greatest is another matter altogether.

On pure talent and accomplishments alone, Schumacher belongs in the same bracket as the very best in the history of the sport - the likes of Juan Manuel Fangio, Stirling Moss, Jim Clark, Jackie Stewart, Gilles Villeneuve, Alain Prost and Ayrton Senna.

Michael Schumacher
Schumacher's talent is widely admired, less so his morals
But greatness is about more than ability and trophies. It is also about character and integrity, and that is where Schumacher's claim falls down.

Many of Schumacher's greatest races - breathtaking against-the-odds performances such as his victories at Barcelona 1996, Belgium 1997, Hungary 1998 and Canada 2003 - will go down in the annals of the sport.

Turning Ferrari, with the help of a few key lieutenants, from a legendary name famous mostly for failure into the most efficient winning machine in F1 history is another remarkable achievement.

And many other, less well known, snapshots of his genius have been afforded to those privileged to have watched him from close quarters at Grands Prix.

This writer, for example, still marvels at how he wrestled his pig of a Ferrari onto the front row of the grid in Argentina in 1996.

Michael Schumacher
Schumacher has helped turn Ferrari into a winning machine
These are memories that will live forever - of one of the finest drivers in history transcending the limits of his car and the conditions to produce moments of the purest sporting genius.

On a personal level, too, I have no problem with Schumacher. He might be hard to get to one-to-one, but once you pin him down he is always affable, pleasant and helpful.

But with all the wonder of Schumacher's talent, and his down-to-earth private persona, comes a dark side. The two are inseparable. And that is what tarnishes his legacy.

Too often - particularly so for one of his talent - Schumacher has relied on the unfair advantage to win, either created by himself with controversial manoeuvres on the track or in various means by his backers off it.

Sadly, the length of the list of these incidents rivals that of his best drives.

Michael Schumacher and Ferrari team boss Jean Todt face the media after the German was thrown out of the 1997 world championship
Schumacher has sometimes been in trouble with the authorities
Few would have said Damon Hill deserved to be world drivers' champion in 1994 more than Schumacher, but the circumstances in which the German won his first title clouded the achievement.

And there have been few years since then in which Schumacher has not been involved in some row or another.

In the first few seasons of his career, as Schumacher protested his innocence in these incidents, many observers were prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt.

But, as the evidence has stacked up against him, an increasing number have come to accept this as an indelible part of Schumacher's character.

P Parkinson

In moments of extreme pressure - and sometimes not even then - his first reaction is often to protect his position by unsporting means.

For a long time, his elevated status in the sport insulated him from the severest public criticism, which tended to come from the media and other outsiders, and was thus more easily shrugged off.

But in recent years the indulgence with which he is treated has evaporated, which explains why the gamesmanship he employed to stop qualifying in Monaco this year met with such a violent reaction from his fellow drivers.

Michael Schumacher passes Jean Alesi's Benetton, with Giancarlo Fisichella's Jordan behind, on his way to victory in the 1997 Belgian Grand Prix
Spa 1997 was one of Schumacher's greatest victories
Tolerance of what many now see as little better than cheating has been at an all-time low this season.

Partly this is out of a sense that time was running out on his career, but just as much it is a case of many of his peers finally feeling that enough was enough.

Few would concur with Jacques Villeneuve's recent claim that Schumacher's questionable ethics mean that "the day he hangs up his helmet people will just forget him" - his 90 Grand Prix wins and seven world titles, plus all his other achievements, will ensure quite the opposite.

But what Villeneuve calls his "lack of class" certainly means Schumacher will not be remembered in quite the way he might have wanted.

Schumacher to quit at end of year
10 Sep 06 |  Formula One
Thoughts on Schumacher
10 Sep 06 |  Formula One
Schumacher's career in photos
10 Sep 06 |  Motorsport
Schumacher win boosts title hopes
10 Sep 06 |  Formula One
Villeneuve slates Schumi 'lies'
18 Aug 06 |  Formula One
Schumacher defends Monaco conduct
28 May 06 |  Formula One
Schumacher not a cheat - F1 boss
28 May 06 |  Formula One
Schumacher's chequered history
28 May 06 |  Formula One
Schumi 'pondering two more years'
29 Apr 06 |  Formula One
Schumi breaks Senna pole record
22 Apr 06 |  Formula One


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Daily and weekly e-mails | Mobiles | Desktop Tools | News Feeds | Interactive Television | Downloads
Sport Homepage | Football | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League | Tennis | Golf | Motorsport | Boxing | Athletics | Snooker | Horse Racing | Cycling | Disability sport | Olympics 2012 | Sport Relief | Other sport...

Help | Privacy & Cookies Policy | News sources | About the BBC | Contact us