Skip to main contentAccess keys helpA-Z index

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
watch listen BBC Sport BBC Sport
Low graphics|Help
Last Updated: Monday, 5 March 2007, 10:13 GMT
Scottish League is 'out of date'
The Scottish Football League has been described as out-dated in a report commissioned by itself.

Accountancy firm Pannell Kerr Foster concluded that the SFL was "an organisation not suited to a modern-day business environment".

The report also says that employees are institutionalised and demoralised - and the secretary's salary is excessive.

It also found that the SFL is three times more expensive to run than equivalent leagues in England.

There, the Nationwide Conference has four employees looking after 68 clubs, while the SFL has 14 people running leagues with 30 clubs.

The Scottish Football League, which runs Scotland's First, Second and Third Divisions, lacks a "commercial engine", according to the report.

It also raises the question as to whether the restructuring of the organisation of Scottish professional league football should be considered

PKF report

It is presently without a sponsor for the league and its knock-out competition, the Challenge Cup, after Bell's withdrew in 2006.

And a number of First Division clubs are pressing for a breakaway league to become a second-tier to the Scottish Premier League, which set up its own separate structure some years ago.

The First Division clubs meet on Thursday and it is likely that this report will be the sole item on the agenda.

PKF's reports stated: "Our review of non-financial matters indicate an organisation which is not wholly suited to the modern-day business environment, or the size of the league."

The report says that much of the disparity between the costs of the SFL and the Conference were due to the "high remuneration of the SFL secretary".

"The secretary's salary package was negotiated prior to the establishment of the SPL and when revenues were up to 65% higher than the current level," it stated.

"There is uncertainty as to why a review of the secretary's contract was not undertaken at the time of the SPL split.

"We believe the current payroll cost could be further reduced by approximately 100,000."

The report compared three options: the status quo (Option A), a 10-club SPL2 breakaway leaving the SFL with 20 clubs but continuing the CIS Insurance Cup (Option B) and a 20-club league without the CIS Cup (Option C).

Under Option B, Second Division clubs would see their annual allocation from the SFL fall in 2008 from 69,000 to 60,000, with Division Three incomes falling from 59,000 to 50,000.

Under Option C, the incomes fall to 44,000 for Division Two clubs and 37,000 for those in Division Three.

The report concludes that "it also raises the question as to whether the restructuring of the organisation of Scottish professional league football should be considered".

However, the clubs promoting a breakaway believe that they could compensate for their loss of 80,000 per club by way of a new television contract and replacing the CIS Cup with a new knock-out competition involving the present SPL clubs and those joining SPL2.

Chick Young's view
05 Mar 07 |  Scotland
Leading clubs want SPL 2 action
11 Dec 06 |  Scottish League
Scots league rejects SPL2 plans
21 Sep 06 |  Scottish League


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Daily and weekly e-mails | Mobiles | Desktop Tools | News Feeds | Interactive Television | Downloads
Sport Homepage | Football | Cricket | Rugby Union | Rugby League | Tennis | Golf | Motorsport | Boxing | Athletics | Snooker | Horse Racing | Cycling | Disability sport | Olympics 2012 | Sport Relief | Other sport...

Help | Privacy & Cookies Policy | News sources | About the BBC | Contact us