BBC Sport football


Related BBC sites

Page last updated at 15:26 GMT, Sunday, 1 February 2009

Newcastle 1-1 Sunderland

By Sam Lyon

Shola Ameobi
Ameobi scores the crucial equalising penalty at St James's Park

Shola Ameobi marked his first start for Newcastle since 21 December with a goal as the Magpies held Sunderland to a draw in an enthralling Tyne-Wear derby.

A frantic end-to-end game could have gone either way, but Ameobi's penalty earned his side a point after Steed Malbranque had fouled Steven Taylor.

Djibril Cisse had scored the opener, the Frenchman beating the offside trap to find the net at the second attempt.

Both sides hit the woodwork chasing the win, but a draw was the right result.

A point apiece did little to ease either side's worries about the drop, especially Newcastle, who are now just a point above the bottom three with matches against Everton, Arsenal, Manchester United, Chelsea, Liverpool and Aston Villa still to come this season.

Kinnear disappointed not to beat Sunderland

It was a frantic encounter, played in front of a red hot St James's Park crowd, which included Magpies owner Mike Ashley, who was in attendance for the first time since September.

Tyne-Wear derbies are rarely tame affairs, but even lofty pre-match expectations that this would be a dogfight of a match were surpassed.

Both sides were a testament to tenacity and determination, with the touch paper well and truly lit in just the second minute when a late challenge on Magpies keeper Steve Harper by Anton Ferdinand prompted a shoving match that underlined the two sides' fierce rivalry.

But the match was not short in quality either and after Ameobi and Kenwyne Jones had efforts blocked, Richardson drew gasps from the home crowd when his floated free-kick evaded everyone and struck the far post.

Harper, Newcastle's new number one keeper thanks to Shay Given's impending departure for Manchester City, had little chance with that effort, and he was beaten again when Jones struck the rebound goalwards, only for new boy Kevin Nolan to clear off the line.

However, Harper proved an able replacement for Given, and the hosts had him to thank when he turned Cisse's cross-come-shot over the bar minutes later.

That came after Andy Carroll had struck the bar at the other end, his header from Jose Enrique's cross looping onto the top of the woodwork, but when Cisse grabbed the opener just after the half hour it was reward for some impressive counter-attacking play from the visitors.

Dean Whitehead was the creator with a looped pass which found Cisse in space, played onside by Fabricio Coloccini, and the French striker finished at the second attempt after Harper had parried his initial effort.

Sbragia laments 'soft' penalty

Newcastle responded with Carroll blazing narrowly high and wide of the Sunderland goal, but it was not until after half-time that the hosts really began to trouble the Black Cats defence.

First George McCartney had to be alert to clear a goalbound header from Sunderland teammate Danny Collins over the bar.

And then referee Howard Webb's brave - and correct - decision not to award a spot-kick when Damien Duff tumbled over Ferdinand's challenge denied Newcastle a golden chance to get themselves back on level terms.

It only delayed the leveller, though, and it was not without controversy when it came as Taylor stepped across Malbranque in the box, went down under the Frenchman's innocuous challenge and Ameobi blazed the resultant penalty home.

If Newcastle fans hoped that would fire their side to further glories, though, they were wrong and it took a stunning last-gasp challenge from the impressive Sebastien Bassong to deny Jones at the other end, before Richardson powered a free-kick over moments later.

In a frantic finale both sides went for broke, Taylor heading straight at Marton Fulop and Ameobi contriving to miscontrol with the goal at his mercy six yards out for Newcastle, while Reid blazed over when well placed for Sunderland.

However, the best chance of the lot fell to Michael Chopra, who broke free of the Newcastle defence but inexplicably attempted to square to Jones instead of shooting, and Andy Reid curled wide with practically the last kick of the match.

And so, both sides had to settle for the draw, extending Newcastle's winless run to eight matches and making it just one win in seven for Sunderland.

Newcastle manager Joe Kinnear:
"There were turning points in the game and I don't think - again - the big decisions have gone our way, but that's the way it is going for us at the moment.

"We were camped in their half for most of the game and so I have to be heartened by our character today, very much so.

"As for transfers before tomorrow, I've got two players lined up who we've been speaking to and I'm confident we will get those in.

"And as for outgoings, we're waiting on Shay Given and Charles N'Zogbia's situations. There's a sticking point over Given's move to Manchester City, with a lot of haggling going on, so we will have to wait and see on both of those two. I hope they go through soon, though, so I can go and spend that money."

Sunderland boss Ricky Sbragia:
"It was a fast and furious match between two very open teams. We had the better of the first half but we really needed the second goal to kill the game.

"Credit to Newcastle, though, they dominated the second half. However, I don't think their's was a penalty - Taylor has played the five card trick and the officials have bought it.

"Still, even though we could have snatched the win at the end, I think a draw was probably the fair result."

Newcastle: Harper, Taylor, Bassong, Coloccini (Edgar 90), Jose Enrique, Gutierrez, Butt, Nolan, Duff, Carroll (Lovenkrands 82), Ameobi.
Subs Not Used: Krul, Xisco, Geremi, LuaLua, Donaldson.

Booked: Butt, Duff.

Goals: Ameobi 69 pen.

Sunderland: Fulop, Bardsley, Ferdinand, Collins, McCartney, Edwards (Reid 71), Whitehead, Richardson, Malbranque (Leadbitter 90), Cisse (Chopra 55), Jones.
Subs Not Used: Colgan, Murphy, Yorke, Healy.

Booked: Bardsley, Richardson, McCartney, Ferdinand.

Goals: Cisse 32.

Att: 52,084

Ref: Howard Webb (S Yorkshire).

BBC Sport Player Rater man of the match: Sunderland's Djibril Cisse 7.91 (on 90 minutes).

Please note that you can still give the players marks out of 10 on BBC Sport's Player Rater after the match has finished.

Print Sponsor

see also
Premier League as it happened
01 Feb 09 |  Premier League
Sunday's football photos
01 Feb 09 |  Football

related bbc links:

related internet links:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2017 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.