Boss Dean Thomas was deflated after seeing Hinckley United concede a late goal in their 1-1 draw at Workington.
The Blue Square North strugglers went ahead before half-time when Owen Story crossed to Leon Jackson, who scored with a fine looping header.
But Michael Reed shot home in injury-time to earn Town a point.
Thomas told BBC Radio Leicester: "We're bitterly disappointed that we didn't collect all three points but our performance was oustanding."
He added: "Our work ethic was magnificent. We were organised and disciplined and I thought it was an excellent performance."