He made 36 against the Warriors in Pietermaritzburg eight days ago.
With the Dolphins chasing the Titans' 242, they were reduced to 19-2 when Pietersen came in but he was quickly dismissed by Ethy Mbhalati who claimed his third wicket of the match.
South African-born Pietersen is desperate to get back to his best for the series in Australia after a disappointing summer in which he made just one score of over 50 in Test cricket.
He has not scored a Test century since March 2009 and was dropped for the one-day series against Pakistan this year after he averaged only 23.33 in one-day games with a highest score of 80 in the Tests.
He joined Surrey on loan from Hampshire in September in a bid to recapture his form and had mixed success, scoring a century in a 40-over game against Sussex but following it up with a second-ball duck against Glamorgan.
Pietersen, 30, began his career with Natal before joining English county side Nottinghamshire in 2001.
Sir Ian Botham, the hero of England's 1981 Ashes win, believes England can emerge victorious in this winter's series and that two of Anderson's fellow bowlers could prove vital.
"I think England have the best chance since they won over there in 1986/87," he told BBC Sport.
"Graeme Swann is absolutely crucial, and England's choice of taking Chris Tremlett for the height on the Australian wickets was a very good and a very brave call.
"It's a massive experience going out there with bigger stadiums then you are used to - on Boxing Day there will be 100,000 screaming Aussies in Melbourne wanting your blood.
"If they don't get the startled rabbit and enjoy the atmosphere, England will win.
"I've had to listen a lot to gloating Australian commentators. It has made my blood boil and I want to be the one gloating in February and I think it will happen.
"[Australia captain] Ricky Ponting could be in an embarrassing position. He could lose three times to England."
This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.