BBC Sport cricket

IN ASSOCIATION WITH

Related BBC sites

Page last updated at 08:47 GMT, Sunday, 1 February 2009

Result U-turn for 2006 Oval Test

Umpire Darrell Hair shows the ball to Pakistan's Inzamam-ul-Haq
Umpire Darrell Hair was at the centre of the Oval controversy

The result of the controversial 2006 Oval Test between England and Pakistan has been switched back to an England win by the game's world governing body.

The match was originally awarded to England by forfeit when the Pakistan team delayed play after being accused of ball-tampering by the umpires.

Last July, the International Cricket Council changed the result to a draw.

But the ICC board decided to reverse that decision at a meeting in Perth, Australia on Sunday.

It means that the series result will once again appear as a 3-0 England victory in the record books.

606: DEBATE
ICC chief executive Haroon Lorgat said the decision ensured "the integrity of the game".

He added: "After reconsidering that match, taking into account the views of the MCC, some of the legal opinions we've got, the board was pretty unanimous in upholding the original umpires' decision.

The original incident occurred on the fourth day of the match in August 2006 when on-field umpires Darrell Hair and Billy Doctrove awarded England five penalty runs after ruling that the Pakistan team had tampered with the ball to help it swing.

Pakistan initially refused to resume play after tea and by the time captain Inzamam-ul-Haq led his players out of the dressing room, the umpires had already called the game off and awarded it to England, the first time a Test has ever been won by forfeit.

Inzamam was subsequently cleared of the ball-tampering charge by an ICC tribunal, but banned for four matches for bringing the game into disrepute by refusing to resume play.

Pakistan, meanwhile, blamed Hair for the whole affair and he was dropped from the ICC's elite umpiring panel in November 2006.

MCC's unanimous viewpoint has always been that the umpire's decision must stand

MCC world cricket committee chairman Tony Lewis
He responded by taking the ICC to an industrial tribunal, alleging racial discrimination, but withdrew the allegation after a week of evidence and the case collapsed.

Pakistan later agreed to play a Twenty20 match in England in 2012 and waive their fee for that match by way of compensation for the loss of the final day's play of the Oval Test.

Hair was restored to the ICC panel in July last summer but only stood in two Tests before announcing his retirement in order to take up the post of executive officer of the New South Wales Umpires and Scorers Association.

The ICC's original decision to change the result of the game to a draw was condemned at the time by the MCC, the guardians of the laws of cricket, who accused the governing body of setting a "very dangerous precedent".

A club statement issued at the time said the move contravened law 21.10, which stated that the ICC had no power to alter results, "whether it feels them to be 'inappropriate' or otherwise".

Former England captain Tony Lewis, now chairman of the MCC's world cricket committee, welcomed the ICC's reversal of its original decision.

"While fully appreciating the sensitive nature of these discussions, and the issues surrounding them, MCC's unanimous viewpoint has always been that the umpire's decision must stand as Law 21.10 is unequivocal," he said.

"We appreciate the co-operation and communication that exists between ourselves and ICC and will continue to work closely with them.

"Importantly, however, we will also continue to speak out in the interests of cricket and its players."

Print Sponsor


see also
Oval Test result changed to draw
03 Jul 08 |  Cricket
Pakistan seek Oval result change
11 Jan 08 |  Cricket
Hair 'hell' over forfeited Test
01 Oct 07 |  Cricket
Is tampering law right?
28 Sep 06 |  Laws & Equipment
Disrepute ban for skipper Inzamam
28 Sep 06 |  Pakistan


related bbc links:

related internet links:
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


BBC iD

Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2017 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.