news vote 2001search vote 2001
 You are in: Vote2001
Main Issues 
Crucial Seats 
Key People 
Results &  Constituencies 
Opinion Polls 
Online 1000 
Virtual Vote 
Talking Point 
Voting System 
Local Elections 

N Ireland 

BBC News

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Debating the figures
Health Secretary Alan Milburn & Lib Dem spokesman on health Nick Harvey
 real 28k

Conservative spokesman on health, Dr Liam Fox
"The government have made this the sacred cow of policy in health"
 real 56k

The BBC's Niall Dickson
"The ambition now is to get rid of waiting lists altogether"
 real 56k

Friday, 11 May, 2001, 10:09 GMT
Waiting list drop hailed
Surgeons at work
Labour says it has met its 1997 election pledge
Labour says it has exceeded its pledge to reduce hospital waiting lists in England.

Health Secretary Alan Milburn said the number of people waiting for surgical operations had fallen by 26,000 in the first three months of the year.

This is the biggest fall since records began

Alan Milburn
This, he said, meant Labour had met its 1997 election pledge to reduce hospital waiting lists by 100,000. The figure now stands at 1,006,600 compared with 1,158,000 when the party came to power.

Mr Milburn said the figures, released on Friday, showed Labour was delivering on the NHS - a claim hotly disputed by the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats.

The Opposition parties suggest that Labour's focus on waiting list numbers has meant hospitals have distorted clinical priorities in order to reduce the figures more quickly.

'Biggest fall'

Speaking at Labour's daily news conference in London, Mr Milburn said: "In March 1997, we said we would cut waiting lists by 100,000.

"We have exceeded that. They have fallen by 150,000 with Labour."

Inpatient list
June 1997: 1,158,000
March 2001: 1,006,600
"The main commitment has now been met for 13 months in succession. This is the biggest fall since records began.

"The Conservatives claim waiting lists are higher. Their claim is wrong. Mr Hague should now take his posters down. They are no longer believable, much like his tax and spending programme."

Outpatient list
June 1997: 295,000
March 2001: 283,000
Mr Milburn rejected claims that surgical waiting lists were reduced by making the outpatient lists longer - it fell by 115,000 to 283,000 in the first quarter of the year.

Policy under fire

But the Liberal Democrats say Labour's failure to tackle the problem sooner has caused suffering for many patients.

Lib Dem health spokesman Nick Harvey
Mr Harvey said Labour should have done more
Its health spokesman Nick Harvey said: "Are Labour really expecting a pat on the back for doubling waiting lists, and achieving a big drop in figures in the month before polling day?

"The pledge card promise has been a cross to bear for four years. It has distorted priorities and meant the number of people waiting to get on waiting lists has soared.

"The fact is that waiting lists are still higher than when Labour came to power. Hundreds of thousands of people have suffered pain and misery because Labour woke up far too late to the need for investment in doctors and nurses."

'Obsessed with spin'

Shadow health secretary Liam Fox said Labour was "spinning" the figures.

"Labour are still more obsessed with spin doctors than doctors. Patients should believe their own experiences not Labour's fiddled figures.

"Labour said they would cut numbers waiting by 100,000 in their 1997 pledge card.

Shadow health secretary Liam Fox
Mr Fox: Labour has failed to achieve its pledge
"In March 1997 the number of in and out patients waiting in England and Wales was 1,502,000. In June 2001 there are 1,442,000. This is a reduction of 60,000. They have failed to honour their pledge.

Labour's concentration on waiting list numbers has come in for much criticism in recent years in both political and medical circles.

There have been suggestions that some hospitals have been prioritising relatively simple operations because they can reduce their waiting lists more quickly.

However, this has meant some patients with more serious illnesses are being left to wait for their operation.

Both the Conservatives and Lib Dems have called for the emphasis to be changed to waiting times instead of numbers on lists.

Labour has pledged to reduce out-patient waiting times to three months, and waiting times for surgery to six months by the end of 2005, as part of its NHS modernisation programme announced last year.


Latest stories

Issues: Economy

Issues: Health




The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Related stories:

21 Feb 01 |  Facts
Waiting lists
27 Jul 00 |  NHS reform
Blair unveils NHS blueprint