| Accrington 3-2 Bury | R |
| Bradford 2-2 Port Vale | R |
| Bradford win 5-4 on penalties | |
| Chesterfield 1-3 Carlisle | R |
| Leeds United 3-1 Grimsby | R |
| Leyton Orient 1-1 Hereford | R |
| Hereford win 3-2 on penalties | |
| MK Dons 3-1 Northampton | R |
| Swindon 0-0 Norwich | R |
| Norwich win 5-3 on penalties | |
&m=20091204152410){kind=small}