Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help
Monday, June 29, 1998 Published at 07:47 GMT 08:47 UK


Talking Point


Should President Clinton push China on human rights?

President Clinton is on a landmark visit to China.

On his arrival in the country, the Chinese government said Mr Clinton's visit heralded a new stage of development in relations between the two countries.

But back home in the US, there has been pressure on the president to take a hard line with the Chinese authorities over the issue of human rights.

Reports of editorial suppression in China and the detention of dissidents by the Chinese authorities have cast a cloud over proceedings.

They have also pushed the issue of human rights to the forefront.

Both republicans and the American public wanted the president to make an expression of world feeling at a ceremony in Tiananmen Square - where Chinese authorities killed pro-democracy activists in violent clashes in 1989.

The president said he fully intended to tackle the issue of personal freedom in China.

And in address to students at Beijing University, he has urged the Chinese Government to respect the basic human rights of its people, arguing that "freedom strengthens stability".

But he also wants to respect Chinese protocol. Any strong words to the Chinese President Jiang Zemin will therefore only be spoken in private.

But should President Clinton overlook protocol on this important visit? Should he take full advantage of the opportunity and be tough and open with China on this issue?

Critics say the president is reneging on his pre-election promise to make China improve its human rights record.

They add that if he has to go to China at all, the issue of human rights should be raised openly with the Chinese Government.

What do you think?

Should President Clinton push China on human rights?

Some comment so far:

It's vital President Clinton tackle human rights in a strong and open manner but it' s a question of timing...
Christopher Wayne, UK

All the world remembers the terrible scenes in Tiananmen Square - the Chinese President must talk about it openly before China can truly move on...
Amanda Joyce, US

Your reaction in full





Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©



  Your reaction in full







Live Talking Points

Are the British born to lose?

Are UFOs a sign of alien life?

NHS at 50: Flagship or shipwreck?

Could a total ban on drinking and driving ever work in Europe?

Is winning everything?

Is Britain a racist society?

Are the marchers out of step?





Previous Talking Points

Are women better drivers than men?

Should English be the EU's only official language?

Does divorce cause children lasting damage?

Is astrology just science fiction?