That was pretty much what you'd all decided, except in your CBBC Newsround Online vote for your fave lad, Chris actually came out ahead of Anton by 8.91% to 8.17%
So maybe some of you are really annoyed!
The lucky lads will now go head-to-head with their rival girl band for the Christmas number one.
The girls' line-up will be unveiled on Saturday night.
But the big question is what will happen to them all after Christmas? Will they be Hear'Says or Libertys?