This time round, the Popstars reject impressed the judges with his version of Christmas classic When A Child Is Born.
Jessica's the latest to go
But Jessica Garlick wasn't quite so lucky. The 20-year-old was fighting back the tears after she scored the least phone votes from the audience.
However, her performance of the Shakin' Stevens number Merry Christmas Everyone was praised by judges.
Pete Waterman said she had "a very professional voice" but didn't think she could make it as a pop idol.
But Jessica insists she can still be a star and said: "The public put me here so they must agree."