BBC Home
Explore the BBC



Last Updated: Tuesday February 08 2011 12:55 GMT

Single Review: Robbie Williams & Gary Barlow - Shame

Robbie Williams and Gary Barlow are reunited with new single Shame

Release date

4 October 2010.

The style

When Robbie Williams split from Take That in 1995, thousands of their fans across the country cried for days.

Fast forward 15 years and now Robbie and Gary Barlow, another member of Take That, have reunited to make this new single - and it's probably going to make your mum really happy to see them back together!

Even if you haven't heard their music from the first time around, you may well still like this pop song, which sees the boys say sorry to one another about arguments they had in the past.

The words

This is a really sweet song, where Robbie and Gary spend the whole time apologising to one another for all the bad things they said in the past.

Robbie Williams and Gary Barlow say sorry to each other in their latest single, Shame
Robbie and Gary say sorry to each other in their latest single, Shame

If you've ever fallen out with a friend and then made up, you'll know EXACTLY what they're talking about.

It's quite a meaningful song but it still has a cheeky sense of humour and the words will leave you feeling happy.

Will you still be humming it next week?

It's not the catchiest tune but it's definitely one you can sing along to when it comes on the radio.

Will it make the charts?

Take That still have loads of fans who will be very happy to see Robbie and Gary back together, but quite a lot of you might like this song as well.

Robbie is also set to rejoin the rest of the band to release new music later in the year, and if this single is anything to go by they're bound to have lots of hits.

NR rating:

Three out of five

Sorry this page is now closed. Please go to the main Reviews page to check out the latest!

Your Comments

"This is a really good song!"

Erin, 10, Scotland

"I love this song. It really is fantastic!"

Emily, 13, Cornwall, England

"Legendary song!"

Josh, 14, Surrey, England

"This song is AMAZING. I can't wait for Take That's new album. I think it's a good idea to release a song like this, as it's a chance to show that Gary and Robbie are friends again!"

Millie, 12, Sussex, England

"This song could be good if it was just sung by Gary Barlow. I think Robbie has a cheek to come crawling back to Take That after his solo career has pretty much died now!"

David, 13, Edinburgh, Scotland

"I think the song Shame is the best in the world! I could listen to it 24/7! I also think that Gary and Robbie have voices that go really well together."

Daniel, 10, Portsmouth, England

"I love this song, it's totally awesome! I could listen to it all day!"

Millie, 10, Bedfordshire, England

"I think it's a good song and I like Gary Barlow. My mum and I think that Shame is a FAB song and we love it!"

Katy, 10, Luton, England

"This song is AMAZING, but I don't really like the video."

Emily, 8, Plymouth, England

"It's OK, but is a bit cheesy! I hope they will make more songs together!"

Sanna, 11, Yorkshire, England

"I love this song and I think it really suits their voices."

Morgan, 10, Hertfordshire, England

"I love the song! GO ROBBIE AND GARY!"

Jodi, 10, London, England

"AMAZING! It's so addictive to listen to!"

Connor, 12, Scotland

"I think this song is rubbish. Even my mum did not like it and she loves Robbie Williams!"

Jasmine, 11, Toulouse, France

"I really like this song because it's all about friendship - how they fell out and became friends again. Plus, it's just seriously catchy!"

Lauren, 10, North Yorkshire, England

"Not a hit, but the words have meaning so it is a good emotional song for the duo."

Heather, 11, Manchester, England

"It is very moving and it really talks to you."

Becky, 12, Kent, England

"I love it! I hope it is the first of many."

Kate, 10, Leeds, England

"When I heard it I thought it was just being sung by Robbie because you can hardly hear Gary! Sorry Gary!"

Maddie, 10, Oxfordshire, England

"Robbie and Gary are back! Their new song is so cool!"

Lauren, 11, England

"Aw! It's a very sweet song, and really speaks to you!"

Amy, 10, Renfrewshire, Scotland

"Too cheesy!"

Joe, 9, Bradford, England

"One of the worst songs ever! I was looking forward to hearing it but I was very disappointed. The lyrics are good but it sounds too old!"

Sean, 11, Ireland

"I think it's a great song, and I'm glad they're friends again."

Annie, 8, West Sussex, England

"Amazing, I love it. They are great!"

Megan, 13, UK

"Not my usual type of music but I think it's really sweet!"

Martha, 11, London, England

"I would say I like the song but I don't really like the music video because I think it is quite sad!"

Rebecca, 12, Lancashire, England

"I love it! Especially as it's two good friends who have got back together."

Sarah, 10, Aberdeen, Scotland

"This may not be the most catchiest of songs, but it's brilliant that the two are back together!"

Ashei, 12, England

"Even though this isn't my favourite song, I think it's really good! I'm so happy they're friends again after all those years of arguing!"

Amy-Leigh, 13, England

"I love this song so much! I rate it 10 out of 10! Brilliant."

Gabbie, 6, London, England

"I love the song, it's so good!"

Sophie, 14, Berkshire, England


Megan, 12, Surrey, England

"I think this single is so cool and amazing."

Holly, 8, England

"I love this song. I think it's good for them to have said sorry and to have made a song together. The song sounds really nice and parts of the tune stick in your head."

Rebecca, 11, London, England

"I don't like it too much, they could have done something better."

Alba, 12, Burgos, Spain

"I think it's a great song and I am glad they like each other now."

Adam, 11, Kent, England

"I liked this song the first time I heard it, but after listening to it a couple of times it gets super boring."

Amelia, 10, UK

"I think it's a great and lovely song and I am happy they do it together."

Toby, 10, Pembrokeshire, England

"It's really good, they should do things like this more often!"

Lukiey, 14, Portsmouth, England

"Not that good really, I expected better."

Olivia, 11, West Midlands, England

"I love this song, it's mint!! I LOVE Gary Barlow and Robbie and Take That. I went to see them on their tour last year."

Georgia, 10, York, England

"I like the new song and I hope they will get to number one in the charts!"

Ellie, 11, Cumbria, England

"They sound exactly the same."

Bobbi, 10, London, England

"It was really good. They make a great team and I like it because it's an emotional song."

Katy, 10, Luton, England

"It's weird how it's sad and happy at the same time. It was so long before I was even born that they split and now thankfully they're back together! TAKE THAT!"

Amira, 10, Birmingham, England

"I don't know what to make of this song. People say it will grow on me but I'm not too sure."

Ella, 13, Dorset, England

"It's OK, not the best song ever."

Owen, 10, Coventry, England

"I like it. And the video is good as well!"

Vinny, 12, Somerset, England

"I think it is good that Robbie and Gary are back together again!"

Erin, 8, Kent, England

"They sound really good together!"

Lucy, 11, London, England

"I think it's really good that they're back together and it is a great song and video too!"

Alice, 9, West Midlands, England

"It's great to see both great singers back together. The song is quite good."

Zara, 14, Birmingham, England

"I heard this quite a while ago and I agree the tune isn't the catchiest but I keep going over the first line in my head. It makes me want to listen to the song and the video is amazing."

Sabrina, 13, Middlesex, England

"It's great to see Rob and Gaz back, maybe for good! The song is great and tells the story of what happened. Can't wait until the tour next year."

Emily, 12, Cornwall, England

"A-M-A-Z-I-N-G. Number one, DEFINITELY!"

Sam, 9, Pembrokeshire, Wales

"I think it's great they're back together again as a group and their song Shame sounds really good!"

Shona, 10, London, England