BBC Home
Explore the BBC



Last Updated: Thursday July 01 2010 12:44 GMT

What did you think of Doctor Who finale?

Publicity shot for Doctor Who, showing Karen Gillan as Amy Pond and Matt Smith as the Doctor

Actor Matt Smith's first series as the Doctor is over and we want to know what you've thought about it.

Have the new Doctor Who stories kept you entertained? And what about Saturday's finale? Was it too scary, too silly, not funny enough or just right?

How do you think Matt Smith is doing as the Doctor? Are you happy with his assistant Amy Pond?

What have been your highlights of the series and what do you want to see more, or less, of in the next one?

Sorry! These comments are now closed. But there's lots more to talk about on the main Chat index.

Your comments

"This is a really good song. I really love it."

Shannon, 14, Telford, England

"I loved the finale, it was one of my favourite episodes of Dr Who. I like Matt and David equally, they are both brilliant actors in different ways."

Ada, 11, London, England

"I think it was brilliant, I loved it, I think it was the best one yet. He isn't as good as David Tennant though, but the finale was the best series he has done."

Georgya, 13, Hampshire, England

"I LOVED IT SO MUCH!!! It was extraordinary. I loved the part where the Doctor dances like a drunk giraffe at Amy and Rory's wedding, it's hilarious and heart-warming!! Cannot wait for the Christmas special!"

Amreen, 13, Kent, England

"This series was amazing, and there is NO OTHER WORD FOR IT! Well, maybe magnificent or marvellous and MANY MORE! Matt and Karen have made the BEST series yet!"

Laura, 10, Cardiff, Wales

"I thought that the finale was epic. It was amazing."

Callum, 12, Warwickshire, England

"I thought the episode was OK but it wasn't what I expected. I thought it'd be a lot more thrilling but it wasn't. This series has been hard to follow. Matt Smith is good but I enjoyed the David Tennant series more."

Lauren, 12, Lancashire, England

"I loved the episode so much but it was a bit complicated."

Sufyan, 8, Bradford, England

"It was a very good episode and the storyline was good for laughs! The best bit was the end - you thought it was the end for Amy and the Doctor but it was actually the end of Amy and Leadworth!"

Jack, 13, Derby, England

"It was an excellent episode although I kept saying there should be less talking and more action! I hate the new design of the Daleks, they just look plastic! Why did the BBC ruin the Daleks?"

Oscar, 9, North Yorkshire, England

"I thought the final of Doctor Who was a rubbish episode."

Finley, 9, East Lothian, Scotland

"I loved it but it was quite confusing. My favourite bit was with the fez, it was funny. I can't wait until Christmas."

Anna, 8, Chelmsford, England

"The storyline was hard to follow at first and in places it got quite complicated. I soon understood more of what was going on though and I think it was quite good but not as good as other finales. I'm looking forward to the Christmas special."

Lauren, 12, Cardiff, Wales

"I think it was great that Rory came back! He and Amy are so cute together. As for Matt, well, he's brill but David was better."

Zoey, 12, Leeds, England

"I haven't got used to him yet, but I'm getting there. Matt's still doing a good job."

Anniaisse, 8, Andover, England

"I loved Doctor Who, it was AWESOME!! The script writers are very talented to produce something as fantastic as that. At first I found it hard to follow but I think it is safe to say that Matt Smith is in the building. And yes, Fez's are cool. And bowties!"

Lili, 12, Kent, England

"I am the world's biggest Doctor Who fan. Matt Smith is so great and I loved it. I can't wait until the Christmas special."

Violet, 12, London, England

"I thought it was really good and I loved it."

Akash, 11, Manchester, England

"It was amazing but complicated. My friend didn't understand some of it so I had to explain the whole thing to him after the episode. It was fab!"

Amandeep, 13, Southampton, England

"David Tennant will ALWAYS be the best Doctor. The finale was still good but not the best I've seen. The Daleks are getting boring now, they're in every series finale."

Daisy, 12, Northamptonshire, England

"I think Matt's performance as the Doctor is phenomenal. David Tennant was better but Matt is a really good actor with a lot of potential. Karen Gillan as the wonderful Amy Pond is a good match for Matt. I would also like to praise Arthur Darvill for his amazing performance as Rory. Well done to all the Doctor Who cast and crew for making an exciting series. I can't wait until the Christmas special and the new series."

Trav, 14, Gloucestershire, England

"It was amazing, I never knew what would happen next."

Elizabeth, 12, Wirral, England

"Amazing! It's one of the greatest episodes of all time. At first I found the storyline hard to follow, but I got it at the end. Well done Karen, Matt, Steven and all those who worked on the finale!"

Christopher, 10, Northumberland, England

"I loved it!! I think Matt is brilliant and Amy and Amelie are awesome."

Craig, 10, Inverness, Scotland

"I thought it was definitely one of the best finales ever. I really thought Amy was dead but I was soo happy when she came back to life. I can't wait till Christmas."

Kate, 12, Yorkshire, England

"It was the most confusing episode ever, but I loved it! I was screaming and laughing and crying at the same time... I just can't wait for the next series... Matt Smith is actually doing better than David Tennant now."

Justine, 11, Co Louth, Ireland

"Wow. It was amazing and really unexpected. When the Doctor was dying I felt myself start to cry! Congratulations to Matt Smith, he's lived up to David Tennant. The only bad thing was not finding out who the 'silence' is."

Cate, 12, East Grinstead, England

"I thought it was really adventurous. I only wish it was on again soon. I thought they all did fantastically well. Great job Karen and Matt."

Maya, 12, Devon, England

"I loved it! The Doctor is mad. Amy Pond is brilliant. I can't wait for the Christmas special."

Kayleigh, 12, Nottinghamshire, England

"Amazing! The best series of Doctor Who ever!"

Aimee, 12, Putney, England

"I really enjoyed it. I thought the second part was much better than the first part though. I can't wait to see the Christmas episode and I think that Matt Smith and Karen Gillan are both really good - perhaps one of the best pairs yet!"

Jessa, 12, Lanarkshire, Scotland

"I LOVED the final episode. I hope they make more like it. I LOVE MATT SMITH AND KAREN GILLAN. I really can't wait for the Christmas episode. It was complicated and that makes it awesome."

Emily, 13, Nottingham, England

"It's a bit weird, but cool."

Mahad, 8, London, England

"It was extremely confusing and freaky, and I got a bit lost with the story, but I thought it was phenomenal! I really can't wait for the next series."

Morgan, 11, Kent, England

"I thought the Doctor Who finale was brilliant! It was really funny too."

Emily, 9, West Midlands, England

"It was fantastic! I can't wait for the Christmas episode! I think all the characters in last night's episode were fabulous, but Matt and Karen were the best!"

Natasha, 11, Huddersfield, England

"It was brilliant. I turned the volume up full blast and didn't move one bit."

Anais, 9, Bristol, England

"It was amazing! Best finale you could ever have. (David Tennant's one comes in a close 2nd). YOU RULE MATT!"

India-Mae, 12, Sutton, England

"I thought it was good because Amy finally got married and there were two Amys."

Nat, 7, Accrington, England

"I love Karen Gillan and Matt Smith, they are so good in the finale. Doctor Who has changed my life! Thank you Doctor and Amy Pond!"

Elizabeth, 9, Devon, England

"Doctor Who is the best TV show on TV for me at the moment. Matt Smith is brilliant at being the Doctor."

Craig, 9, Cornwall, England

"Your finale is awesome!! I like the stone Dalek and little Amelia, but the weeping angels are the most scariest in the world!"

Leo, 8, London, England

"I think the finale was great because it was all exciting and there was so much tension in the episode! Great work!"

Sammy, 10, Manchester, England

"I have always been scared of Doctor Who, so I must have been crazy to watch it! My dad said my brother wasn't scared of it because he didn't understand it as much as I did. Once I got into it, I did NOT find it a BIT scary! Luckily, I understood it a lot! WELL DONE MATT AND KAREN!!!!"

Caitlin, 9, Berkshire, England

"I thought the episode was fantastic. Matt and Karen at their best if I'm being honest, and I can't wait for the Christmas special."

Dylan, 15, Paignton, England

"I think the stone Dalek was brilliantly designed!"

Harry, 11, Winchester, England

"I thought the finale of Doctor Who this year was absolutely amazing! I loved that whole thing with bringing Rory back, and the Pandorica, and how the Doctor flew it into the heart of the exploding TARDIS. It was brilliant! And the Doctor's dancing at Amy's wedding was genius! I think Matt has done an amazing job portraying the Doctor, I applaud him for his performance, and of course, yeah, the Doctor can buy another fez now!"

Jasmine, 14, Birmingham, England

"Amazing! Steven Moffat and Matt Smith are my new heroes! Love all the scares and I've always wanted Doctor Who to be more timey wimey wibbley wobbly. Love, love, LOVE it!"

Chris, 11, Manchester, England

"I think that Matt was very good."

Alice, 9, Hartlepool, England

"I have always loved Dr Who. This series has kind of disappointed me though. It has seemed too complex, and harder to understand than previous series. Amy Pond has got on my nerves, seeming too typical and annoying. The only person who has impressed me has been Matt Smith. He has done a fantastic job. Well done, Matt!"

Maisie, 12, Carnoustie, Scotland

"Matt has really amazed me. At first, I was very unsure whether he could follow after David Tennant, as I was when David followed Christopher Eccleston, but the writers have made him so quirky and brilliantly played by Matt you can't help but become engrossed once more into the series. The Doctor is a lot more aware of how he is perceived by the universe now, and has stopped mourning over Rose, and Amy and Rory are brilliant with him. Slightly worried about River Song though. I love Matt, he's more amazing than I could ever have imagined. I can't get enough of it."

Darcie, 10, Rochester, England

"I loved every second of it! I loved the fact that Rory was back, Amy FINALLY got married and the Doctor saved the day, with the help of River Song. I just can't wait for the next series!"

Hannah, 13, Cardiff, Wales

"It was awesome! The first part of the finale was confusing but it made sense. I've watched it like seven times over! DOCTOR WHO ROCKS!!!!!"

Tamblin, 10, Surrey, England

"I did like it. I couldn't understand it much but it was still good."

Danny, 11, Folkestone, England