BBC Home
Explore the BBC



Last Updated: Thursday December 03 2009 10:28 GMT

Are you listening to Susan Boyle?

Susan Boyle

Britain's Got Talent runner-up Susan Boyle has made history by releasing the best-selling debut album since records began.

I Dreamed a Dream went straight to number one, selling more than all the rest of the top five.

She's an unusual pop star so we want to know if her album is on your Christmas list this year.

Are you listening to SuBo? Or is someone in your family into her music?

Will you buy her album? Or do you prefer to just download singles you like online?

Unfortunately this topic is now closed, but there are Comments pages on other subjects on the main Chat index.

Your comments

"I think that she shouldn't be number one for the album charts. JLS should still have the top place.

Simran, 13, London, England

"I think the only reason Susan Boyle is famous is, when she auditioned for Britain's Got Talent, nobody thought she was talented because of her looks. If she came on that stage looking like she does now, nobody would have been that amazed!"

Livvy, 11, Warwickshire, England

"No, I don't listen to Susan Boyle. I don't think she's very good."

Adeena, 10, Derby, England

"I think Susan Boyle is a really great artist and I did watch her when she was on the X Factor but I haven't got her album."

Holly, 9, Berkshire, England

"Susan is good but you will never see me buying her CD."

Megan, 11, London, England

"I like Susan. No doubt she's a nice women but her songs are way too classical for this century. People like JLS and Lady Gaga are way more popular."

Bethan, 11, Bournemouth, England

"No, I don't listen to Susan Boyle. I don't think she's very good."

Adeena, 10, Derby, England

"No! She is more for elderly people."

Lara, 10, London, England

"My dad listens to it but I don't really like it."

Primrose, 8, West Sussex, England

"My sister is 14- she and her friends have got Susan Boyle's new album and say they love it. But I like JLS better!"

Kerry, 10, London, England

"She isn't my type. In my opinion she's old fashioned she'll be forgotten soon."

Thoma, 10, Durham, England

"I think Susan Boyle is a great artist. I like her music and I am her number one fan!"

Gregory, 11, London, England

"I don't have the Susan Boyle CD but I think she is a talented singer. My Gran is getting it for her Christmas. She will do well!!!"

Allison, 10, Dunblane, Scotland

"I don't have her CD or download her songs but if it's on the radio I would turn it up!"

Megan, 10, Dundee, Scotland

"I don't particularly like Susan Boyle she is a bit strange but she can sing very well!"

Aimee, 12, England

"She is a good singer. but I don't like her style of music. I don't think I would buy her record."

Nicole, 10, Newcastle, England

"I don't listen to Susan Boyle, she is not very good and is a little boring. Also she does not target young adults, she is mainly for people in their late forties."

Maria, 14, Birmingham, England

"I wanted her to win Britain's Got Talent but I don't listen to her now."

Sophie, 13, Cumbria, England

"I think it's boring and she is rubbish, I like music like JLS."

Eoghan, 8, Ireland

"I think that Susan Boyle is a very good singer but she is a bit boring and her music is for old people."

Hiab, 8, Newcastle, England

"I don't really listen to Susan Boyle, as I am not into classical music. However she does have an amazing voice!"

Jessica, 10, London, England

"I don't exactly like Susan Boyle, but I don't dislike her either. Let's put it this way, she's an outstanding singer but her music just isn't my type!!!"

Leah, 11, Manchester, England

"Errr are you mad? I ain't going to listen to her music!"

Maryam, 12, UK

"Well I don't like her that much, her voice is OK but not my type. So I have not brought her CD but that's my opinion."

Sierra, 12, London, England

"No, I have not been listening to Susan Boyle because it just seems weird!"

Lauren, 9, Rochester, England

"I am not going to buy any of her CDs."

Katie, 13, Wales

"No way! She is not good at all really. People are overreacting about the Britain's Got Talent thing!!!"

Claudia, 11, Slough, England

"I like Susan Boyle but I wouldn't buy her music."

Grace, 11, Northamptonshire, England

"I do not like Susan Boyle. I do think her voice is fine but it is more of an old person album."

Alex, 9, Kent, England

"I like listening to her and she is a good singer but she's doesn't really sing my kind of music. I can listen to her once or twice but after a while it gets quite boring!"

Ellie, 10, Hertfordshire, England

"She's good. My nanny loves her music so I sometimes listen to Susan Boyle!"

Charlotte, 9, Plymouth, England

"No, I don't listen to Susan Boyle. She's not very good."

Tilly, 10, Bedford, England

"I think Susan Boyle is good."

William, 10, England

"I don't listen to Susan Boyle. I don't like her and she is way not my type. I like JLS way more than her."

Rebecca, 11, Perthshire, Scotland

"She's OK but her songs are more for older people and I think she should have won Britain's Got Talent."

Anne-Marie, 12, London, England

"When I first saw Susan Boyle she shocked me because of her voice, but I really don't know why she has become as successful as she has. It's not that amazing to be honest."

Shana, 12, Leicester, England

"I don't like her personally. It's not my style. I'm glad Diversity won."

Mariah, 13, Portsmouth, England

"I think Susan Boyle has an amazing voice and deserves all her sales. The album is very diverse and enjoyable and suitable for all ages, so everyone should be buying it!"

Nicky, 12, Cardiff, Wales

"She has a good voice but I'm not buying her CD. I'm not into her really."

Jasmine, 12, UK

"I think she can sing but she isn't good enough for me to buy her albums. I haven't bought her album and I don't think I will."

Faye, 11, Wales

"I listen to Susan Boyle. She has a fabulous opera voice. I love her song Wild Horses."

Jade, 11, Hull, England

"I think Susan Boyle has had her share of fame. In the charts there are many better artists than her."

Rowan, 12, Northamptonshire, England

"She has incredible voice, but I'm not much of a fan of that type of music."

Sophie, 12, England

"I don't like Susan. I heard her once on Britain's Got Talent. That's it-I get bored of her voice. SORRY SUSAN!!"

Charlie, 13, England

"No, I'm not into her at all."

Becky, 13, Nottingham, England

"I think Susan Boyle is fantastic, but I didn't buy her album because she is not my type."

Timothy, 11, East Sussex, England

"She may well be a good singer but I would never buy her album. Give me Cheryl Cole or Take That any day!"

Freya, 14, England

"I do listen to her. In my singing classes we do opera, and I am great at it! We also listen to her when we come in to start our class. We have all met Susan Boyle, and she is a wonderful woman."

Janet, 11, England

"I think Susan Boyle is OK at singing but I'm not really a fan of her."

Megan, 9, Wales

"Susan is a really good singer and her voice really is powerful. But personally I think that children wouldn't enjoy listening to high pitch singing!! "

Faduma, 11, London, England

"I don't really like Susan Boyle's singing. She's good at it though, but it's not my type of music."

Emma, 12, Swansea, Wales

"I think she is alright but I wouldn't listen to her."

Shannon, 11, Derby, England

"Personally I think Susan is a fantastic singer for a certain audience but that's not children."

Omolola, 11, London, England

"No one in my family listens to her music. No, I won't be buying her album."

Charlotte, 14, Melton Mowbray, England

"I wouldn't buy her album because I'm not really into her music but she does have an AMAZING voice!"

Hayley, 14, Gloucestershire, England

"I must admit, she is a great singer, but she just isn't my type."

May, 11, Edinburgh, Scotland

"No. I'm not interested in her to be honest, and I have no idea what all the fuss is about."

Gemma, 13, London, England

"No I don't really like her but I think everyone has different tastes of music."

Emma, 10, Walsall, England

"I haven't got her album yet, but I think she is a really good singer and my mum once cried because Susan was so good!"

Layla, 11, Aberdeen, England

"I think her voice is really good but if I had the choice of her album or Cheryl Cole's I would go with Cheryl!"

Molly, 11, West Midlands, England

"I love Susan Boyle. She is so good."

Sarah, 7, Shetland Islands, UK

"I don't really listen to her but when she was on X Factor I've got to say she was pretty good and she has shown everyone who laughed at her they're wrong."

Grace, 12, London, England

"She is an inspiration to the world, my idol, and I think she is truly amazing!"

Jade, 14, Oxford, England

"My mum likes SuBo. She wants her CD for Christmas."

Louisa, 6, London, England

"My mum pre-ordered it two days before it was released. I have been listening to it ever since and I think that it is good that Susan has had a chance to shine."

Anna, 10, England

"My mum thinks Susan Boyle is really good. Usually I wouldn't listen to her type of music, but actually I think her songs are very haunting and she has an amazing voice!"

Zara, 12, London, England

"I'm not a Susan Boyle fan, but I think she has a great voice. She looks a bit old-fashioned though."

Amy, 11, England

"People are entitled to their own opinion and I think Susan Boyle has done well for herself."

Rachel, 12, Manchester, England

"I think Susan Boyle is really boring. I can't see how she is selling records."

Molly-Anne, 11, Cornwall, England

"I think she is fantastic."

Molly, 9, Northampton, England

"I don't like her music it's not that she hasn't got a good voice, she has, but it's not the kind that I like."

Beth-Anna, 11, Tyne and Wear, England

"She should have won Britain's Got Talent - she has a pure voice! I have her album and I listen to it all the time."

Kamilla, 12, London, England

"I think Susan Boyle is so boring. Whenever I hear her I always seem to yawn!!!"

Rahima, 7, London, England

"She's got an amazing voice but let's face it, she's not what teenagers want to hear. Older people are going to go for her more but I think personally she's going to fizzle out after a few months."

Vaughrie, 13, Dover, England

"I think Susan is amazing she was my favourite on Britain's Got Talent. I do like one of her tunes but I think it's aimed at older people."

Ben, 12, York, England

"I don't like Susan Boyle. I find her music boring."

John, 10, Leicester, England

"I think she's really boring. I prefer pop music and she sings opera type music!"

Kelsie, 10, South Yorkshire, England

"I think her voice is really good but not good enough to entertain kids."

John, 14, Kent, England

"Yes, I like SuBo and would like to buy her album!!! I like to listen to a bit of everything."

Xanthe, 12, Spain

"I think Susan Boyle has a brilliant voice but I think she wasn't as good as Diversity. I haven't bought her album but my mum has for my Nan's Christmas present. I don't know if she will like it though!"

Michael, 13, Berkshire, England

"No, she's a good opera singer, but I'm not into that kind of thing!!!"

Sophie, 11, Glasgow, Scotland

"I have not bought Susan Boyle's record and I probably am not going to because I think older people like her music more."

Alishah, 12, Manchester, England

"I think Subo is a good singer, but she only shocked everyone ONCE. So people don't really like her anymore. Do you think that Simon Cowell still thinks: 'Wow she is so amazing?!'"

Claire, 10, Belfast, Northern Ireland

"I don't like her music but I like to listen to her because my dad bought her album and has only listened to it twice."

Lisa, 12, Manchester, England

"I've not been listening to Susan. Although I must admit she is an outstanding singer and deserved to win Britain's Got Talent!"

Olivia, 12, Manchester, England

"No, I'm not really into classical music but she does have the most powerful voice and she proved everyone wrong!!! So well done Susan Boyle!!!"

Jess, 15, Sussex, England

"I love Susan Boyle, she is sensational. I've met her and she is such a lovely woman. Her music can capture your heart."

Julie, 13, West Lothian, Scotland

"Susan Boyle's rubbish. Everybody loves her but I don't! She sings really high and don't say I have no taste... I do! I like JLS and everybody in the world does."

Jade, 8, England

"I think she is a good singer but is a bit boring. She is more for older people."

Bethany, 10, Sheffield, England

"I have not bought her album. I am not a great fan of hers but she is an OK singer."

Aron, 13, Leigh, England

"I listened to her on Britain's Got Talent but now I wouldn't listen to her normally. She is a good singer but not my type."

Jess, 10, Cambridgeshire, England

"My dad bought her album and has only listened to it twice."

Lisa, 8, Manchester, England