Many of you have been in tears, and say you'll be upset all over Easter.
Natalie, 15, from London, told us: "I cried for more than three hours. I will miss him but I will keep supporting S Club until they really split up."
Fiona, 13, from Billingham, said: "I have been crying for hours but I still love them."
And Joyce, 14, from Holland added: "I cried and cried, and am still crying..."
But however upset you are, most fans reckon they'll stick by S Club no matter what.
In our vote, nearly 70 per cent of you promised to carry on supporting the band - with or without Paul.
Twenty two per cent said they'd wait and see, but only nine per cent of you said you felt betrayed and wouldn't support them anymore.