What do YOU think of McFly's new single?
It's quite good but a bit samey.
Frankie, 13, Chester
I think this song is wicked, and it shows their Beach Boys side. A totally awesome beach choon!!
Sarah, 11, West Midlands
It's AMAZING! So cheery and happy even with the sad ending. A hit 5/5!
Malachy, 14, Bedfordshire
I got their album the first week it came out and I listened to this hundreds of times before it was out. Its getting boring now. However I can't BELIEVE the songs they choose to be the first 2 singles. They were good but there's far better on the album. It should have been Surfer Babe, Met This Girl and That Girl as the first three singles.
David, 12, Cardiff
Not impressed, I'm afraid. McFly can produce great music, they proved that with 5CIHH, but since then, they've gone downhill a bit. This one isn't very catchy, and the girl in the video can't act to save her life. Look at her pretending to laugh at Danny. 2 out of 5 from me.
Liz, 13, Swanley
I think this song is great. McFly are really talented and gorgeous. It deserves to be number 1.
Becki, 12, Leeds
I really like this one! McFly have come up a level from being Busted wannabes and to truly great pop/rock. My one question to everyone is why does only Danny and Tom sing? I would like to hear Harry or Dougie singing as well! Even though Danny and Tom are good!
Lou, 11, Milton Keynes
I think that That Girl is a brilliant!! It has really good lyrics and a really interesting tune! It will go straight to number 1!!!!!!10/10!!
Katie, 11, Wirral
It rocks! It's a little rockier than their other songs. It's got a real cool 60's beach vibe and the video's so funny!
Liz, 14, Dublin
I love it! It's sooooo good! It's got a great feel to it, it's got a story behind it, and the video makes me laugh! I think it's their best yet!
Kate, 13, Aylesbury