Skip to main content Text Only version of this page
BBC
Home
TV
Radio
Talk
Where I Live
A-Z Index
Games
Games
Chat
Chat
Vote
Vote
Win
Win
Quiz
Quiz
Club
Club
 Homepage
 UK
 World
 Sport
 Music
 TV/Film
 Animals
 Sci/Tech
 Weather
 Pictures
 Find Out
 The Team

Contact Us
Help
Teachers





  Your reviews of Popstars 2: The Rivals
Updated 06 October 2002, 13.19
Pop Idol winner Will Young and fellow contestant Gareth Gates perform together at CBBC Prom in the Park 2002
Will Young and Gareth Gates perform at CBBC Prom in the Park

Each week, you get the chance to review something totally fresh.

This week, we wanna know what you think of the latest TV show out of the Popstars stable - Popstars 2: The Rivals.

Geri Halliwell is one of the judges on Popstars 2: The Rivals
Geri Halliwell is on the judging panel

This time it's not just a battle to find the best singer or perfect band, but who's better - boys or girls?

Over the weeks a boy band and a girl band will be selected. The two groups will then release a single at the same time to see who can reach the prized number one spot in the UK charts.

Hear'Say were chosen by the first Popstars series
Hear'Say were chosen by the first Popstars series

But will you be watching? Do you care? Are you an avid fan or do you believe real musical talent can't be manufactured for TV ratings.

Write something that's as interesting as you can, and make it between five and 15 sentences.

Go to the form


Alice, 11, Pontypridd

opening quoteI think Hear'Say were rubbish and manufactured bands aren't that successful. There is no hope for Popstars the rivals but S Club Juniors will have a future.closing quote

Caroline, 13, Cork

opening quoteI think it's no good and that the bands are going to be popular at first and then turn out like hear'Say.closing quote

LaTisha, 14, London

opening quoteI think that popstars the rivals is a very good and enjoyable programme. It gives the chance for others a time to shine and show that they too can make it large. Overall I would give the show a 9/10. closing quote

Emma, 12, Southport

opening quoteI like the show but it's just another cheesy pop band. I'm looking forward to Fame Academy more than I ever looked forward to Popstars because, as well as Cat and Patrick presenting, it's not all pop music. It's got different styles, and it's not all young floozy wannabes.closing quote

Christopher, 12, Glasgow

opening quoteI think it's a cheek that Geri Halliwell is a judge, she can't even sing herself nevermind telling someone else if they can or can't. I think the bands will be a flop like hear'Say. I can't believe I went to their concert.closing quote

Louise, 12, Ipswich

opening quoteI think popstars the rivals will be funny and exciting to watch like popstars and pop idol. I always get addicted to these programmes!! closing quote

Emily, 13, Milton Keynes

opening quotePopstars the Rivals is good fun to watch, but to be honest it is just a load a rubbish making another cheezy manufactured band.closing quote

Luke, 14, Birmingham

opening quoteThe Rivals is wicked, I'm really into it but some parts of it are really kewl! I think Davina Mccall is a wicked host. I think the judges are wicked, Geri is the best one out of all of them. closing quote

Laura, 13, Southampton

opening quoteI love Popstars: The rivals! I love the Romanian twins Katrina and Monica! The show is very good, but will never have has much talent as Pop Idol. No one will replace the talent of Rosie Ribbons and Jessica Garlick (who were the best, in my opinion)closing quote

Lauren, 14, Norwich

opening quoteI think Popstars the Rivals is excellent and I think it's a really good way of finding the raw talent that's out there, but the one thing is that manufactured bands seem to die out after a while. I would however prefer it if they wrote there own songs rather than doing cover versions because then I think people can learn and hear the singers real voices and they can be proud of their own songs.closing quote

Emma, 13, Carrick Fergus

opening quoteI hate the way the bands are formed like that but I love watching the programme cuz I like seeing all the people who really can't sing but think they r wonderful!closing quote

BORDER=0

Your name

Your age

Your town

Your review!

Thanks for sending in your review. We'll publish the best on this page. Some reviews may be edited. If you don't want to use this form, you can also send your review to presspack.reviews@bbc.co.uk
BORDER=0

More InfoBORDER=0
TV/FilmHow to be a star
PicturesPix from Popstars 2 auditions
Club'Pop music's changing'

BORDER=0

Past StoriesBORDER=0
Popstars 2 set for Christmas number one
Pop Idol Hayley to be a host on Popstars 2
Popstars judge still waiting for 'Gareth'
Davina to host Popstars 2

BORDER=0


 


E-mail this page to a friend



Full Club Section
Also in Your Reviews now:
Diaries from a young model, actor, footballer and tennis player All of our talented kids' diaries in one place
© BBC Back to top^^
Homepage | UK | World | Sport | Music | TV/Film | Animals | Sci/Tech | Weather
Pictures | Find Out | The Team | Games | Chat | Vote | Win | Quiz | Club