Skip to main content Text Only version of this page
BBC
Home
TV
Radio
Talk
Where I Live
A-Z Index
Games
Games
Chat
Chat
Vote
Vote
Win
Win
Quiz
Quiz
Club
Club
 Homepage
 UK
 World
 Sport
 Music
 TV/Film
 Animals
 Sci/Tech
 Weather
 Pictures
 Find Out
 The Team

Contact Us
Help
Teachers





  Carrying knives - your views
Updated 30 July 2004, 19.22
Knives
In a recent survey, one in four children aged between 11 and 16 admitted to carrying a weapon - including a knife.

Now the government is considering making it as serious an offence as carrying a gun - which means more than five years in prison.

So how big an issue are knives where you live, or at your school?

Perhaps you carry a knife yourself. If so, let us know why.

And what do you think about the government's new plans to tackle the problem?

Whatever your views, e-mail and let us know.

Unfortunately this topic is now closed but there are Comments pages on other subjects on the main Chat index.

opening quoteI think knives should never be taken into schools, Even if it's for self-defence. They can do damage for life to the person and also to yourself.closing quote
Richard, 14, Hereford

opening quotePeople say it's for defence...well if no one carried knives you wouldn't need one for defence!closing quote
Laura, 14, Southampton

opening quoteI think carrying knives is really dangerous in the hands of the wrong people. I don't think knives should be taken that easily because you really don't know what type of people there are in this world.closing quote
Wai Yin, 14, Kent

opening quoteI don't believe that 1 in 4 children carry knives. Me, my older brother and my mates don't know anyone carrying knives.closing quote
David, 14, Chessington

opening quoteKnives are dangerous things and should only be used for what they are made for. If anyone is found with a knife in a public place it should be treated like a gun.closing quote
Naomi, 11, Kent

opening quoteI was threatened with a knife and I think that the law should be changed and kids should think about what they are doing to other pupils.closing quote
Becky, 12, Bristol

opening quoteDavid Blunkett said that people now carry knives instead of guns as gun laws are so strict. If laws are just as strict for knives, people may decide that they may as well carry a gun instead, which is more dangerous.closing quote
Ben, 12, Sittingbourne

opening quoteI think the new law about knives will not make a difference because some teenagers think it is cool to carry a weapon in school.closing quote
Colin, 10, Kinross

opening quoteI think that knives are very dangerous to carry around, and should be treated the same as a gun. I would feel quite threatened if I knew that someone was carrying a knife in my school. However I do believe that we should have something to protect ourselves from anyone. Not necessarily in school but if we walk home from school or something, just in case.closing quote
Rebecca, 14, Norwich

opening quoteI don't carry a knife - don't know anyone who does, but I think it's pointless to. There's a danger of being 'found out', and there is a jail sentence if you kill. They are wrong, and apart from kitchen use and so on, they should be banned.closing quote
Andrew, 14, Glasgow

opening quoteI think the government should make it as serious an offence as carrying a gun because you're not allowed to bring them into Britain from other countries.closing quote
Kelly, 11, Edinburgh

opening quoteWhy would you take a knife around anyway. For a start you could get arrested, second, apart from killing why would you bring a knife around?closing quote
Luc, 9, Newark

opening quoteKnives are just as deadly as guns which means people will die like people who have been shot.closing quote
Josh, 12, Norwich

opening quoteI agree that carrying a knife should be a serious offence because people will use the knife if it's there, if it's not there then they won't be tempted to use it.closing quote
Jennyfer, 13, Huddersfield

opening quoteIt is totally wrong. It has been proved what the consequences could be. A definite ban should be put in order unless these knives are needed for work etc.closing quote
Sharley, 13, Cumbria

opening quoteKnives are as much of a weapon as guns... however people are used to knives. I mean I have hundreds of very sharp meat knives in my kitchen and I don't worry... if I had hundreds of guns in my kitchen I think I would.closing quote
David, 13, Bedford

opening quoteI think you should be jailed for 5 years if you are found carrying a knife like the law is for guns. Knives can be used in murders and so banning shops selling knives might decrease numbers of murders.closing quote
Zoe, 13, Dundee

opening quoteMy friend carried a knife when he was being bullied. Teachers couldn't stop it and he was so scared of them he wanted to scare them off. He didn't hurt anybody in the end though.closing quote
Haz, 14, Wales

opening quoteI think guns are the weapons you have in action movies and knives are the real life thing. It's a growing problem and I really agree with the government on this one.closing quote
Abigail, 10, Kingston

opening quoteI don't like the idea of carrying a knife because it's very easy to threaten someone's life as if you want them to do something when they don't want to.closing quote
Jim, 14, Yarm

opening quoteI don't actually see any point in carrying knives because you can get yourself in trouble with police and school. In my area people carry knives for safety but that's not safe at all.closing quote
Mahamud, 14, Watford

opening quoteI think knives are very dangerous and that if you go in public places people should be checked for weapons.closing quote
Ibrahim, 14, Wandsworth Town

opening quoteI don't think people should be allowed to carry knives because they are dangerous! They can also do the same thing as guns!closing quote
Amaan, 10, Cardiff

opening quoteCarrying knives is very dangerous and can really harm someone whether meant or not!closing quote
Amy, 14, Nottinghamshire

opening quoteKnives can be just as dangerous as guns so I think carrying one should be treated the same as carrying a gun.closing quote
Tom, 13, Bolton



More InfoBORDER=0
ChatDo you feel safe at school?

BORDER=0

Past StoriesBORDER=0
Boy, 12, buys 68 knives
Calls for schools weapons checks
Crackdown on bullies and weapons
Teen cut in school knife incident

BORDER=0


 


E-mail this page to a friend



Full Chat Section
Also in Your Comments now:
Your views on forced marriages
Your messages for Paula Radcliffe
What did you do for bonfire night?
Who influences you the most? Vote: who influences you the most?
Today's quickfire quiz How well do you know today's news?
Play Rings Slider Challenge Play our tricky Rings Slider game!
Guides A-Z
A clickable list of all our guides
© BBC Back to top^^
Homepage | UK | World | Sport | Music | TV/Film | Animals | Sci/Tech | Weather
Pictures | Find Out | The Team | Games | Chat | Vote | Win | Quiz | Club