Skip to main content Text Only version of this page
BBC
Home
TV
Radio
Talk
Where I Live
A-Z Index
Games
Games
Chat
Chat
Vote
Vote
Win
Win
Quiz
Quiz
Club
Club
 Homepage
 UK
 World
 Sport
 Music
 TV/Film
 Animals
 Sci/Tech
 Weather
 Pictures
 Find Out
 The Team

Contact Us
Help
Teachers





  Did ROTK deserve 11 Oscars?
Updated 04 March 2004, 11.34
Scene from ROTK
This year will be remembered as the one when Lord Of The Rings dominated the Oscars.

The third film in the trilogy - Return Of The King - picked up every single award for which it was nominated.

It went home with a whopping 11 statuettes.

The previous two films had limited success at the Oscars.

Were you pleased that it finally won big? Maybe you thought the Rings films were overrated?

Tell us what YOU think

Unfortunately this topic is now closed but there are Comments pages on other subjects on the main Chat index.

opening quoteYES!!! It definitely deserved it's 11 Oscars - the only problem is that it didn't get all the other awards too! Elijah Wood deserved Best Actor... but I'm REALLY happy that it got all 11!!closing quote
Amanda, 11, USA

opening quoteNo because I think other films should have chances to win such a prestigious award instead of one winning 11!!closing quote
Nouria, 13, London

opening quoteOh, definitely, look at what they are up against. Compared to the other films, LOTR definitely deserved all 11 awards for the hard effort and amazing talent. This film was a phenomenon.closing quote
Lucy, 16, Canada

opening quoteIt deserved more than 11!!! I think that Sean Astin should have been nominated for (and got!) the Best Supporting Actor award. He played Sam so well you could really feel his emotions and he made hundreds of people cry when Frodo said he was going on alone.closing quote
Rachel, 12, Cambridge

opening quoteI don't think LOTR should have won as many Oscars because the film is to long, boring and I fell asleep through the first film. I think that Pirates of the Caribbean should have won more Oscars than LOTR because it is funny, action packed and also Johnny Depp and Orlando Bloom are gorgeous. LOTR is very overrated and a film I do not rate at all.closing quote
Jessica, 15, Newcastle

opening quoteLORD OF THE RINGS! They definitely deserved all 11. They worked so hard on the trilogy and I'm glad they got the Oscars. It's the best film I've seen in ages.closing quote
Charlotte, 15, Hereford

opening quoteI think ROTK is a brilliant film and deserved all of the awards because of all of the work people have done not just the actors but behind the scenes as well.closing quote
Sophie, 14, Biddulph

opening quoteIt didn't deserve one! The Lord of the Rings (or Bored of the Things as I like to call it) series is the worst I have ever had the misfortune to watch! I'm glad it's all over now, and there's more Harry Potter films to come!closing quote
Becca, 15, Huddersfield

opening quoteI am so Happy that LORT won the award because it is just the best film have seen and I think there are all good but the last one was the best.closing quote
Abbas, 14, London

opening quoteI thought that it was very unfair I mean, what's so good about LOTR?closing quote
Charlotte, 13, USA

opening quoteI was surprised they were only nominated for 11. They should have won everythingclosing quote
James, 14, Omagh

opening quoteAlthough it's a great film, I think that it has started to take over the awards, we need more variety!closing quote
Gemma, 14, Nottingham

opening quoteNo the film was good but it wasn't really fair on all the other good films having to compete against Lord of the Rings. The second film was better than the last one anyway.closing quote
Lisa, 12, Coatbridge

opening quoteNo way should it have won 11 Oscars! There were loads of better films! That film was too long. I agree that it was a good film but everyone who participated in the making of it should just GET OVER THEMSELVES!closing quote
Ben, 14, Strood

opening quoteOf course it deserved the 11 Oscars. It's the only film that made me laugh and cry over and over again in three hours - and to all those who say it's too long, you've obviously never seen the film.closing quote
Mandy, 15, Leeds

opening quoteYes of course!! I know quite a few people who don't like it but still agree it deserved the awards because of the massive achievement and effort put into making them and the fantastic results - even if it's not the type of film you like!closing quote
Josh, 13, Suffolk

opening quoteOf course. Although I'm not a big fan of Lord of the Rings, I still think it was the best film of last year.closing quote
Louise, 12, Glasgow

opening quoteDefinitely. If Titanic deserved 11, then ROTK definitely did, and then some. It's just a great film.closing quote
Alex, 13, Milton Keynes

opening quoteIt deserved every single award it won but I do think that Pirates of the Caribbean should have won at least one award because that was an amazing film too.closing quote
Beeta, 13, Surrey

opening quoteNo way! They are such boring films! The shorter the better!closing quote
Tom, 10, Harrogate

opening quoteEverywhere I go it's LotR this LotR that. Come on, it 'aint that good! It is just a decent adventure film...closing quote
James, 13, Durham

opening quoteOf course it deserved 11 Oscars! Anyone who has seen it must agree.closing quote
Will, 14, Kent

opening quoteNo, I love the film and thought it was great but give others a chance. It's not fair it won so many, Oscars should be for all - not just 1 movie.closing quote
Rosie, 14, Northolt

opening quoteSorry everyone I haven't seen any of the three films but I don't think they deserved 11 awards. There are so many different good films out there I mean that's just plain selfish and greedy.closing quote
Danielle, 11

opening quoteNo, definitely not. No film deserves that many Oscars and it isn't even that good a film!closing quote
Hazel, 12, Cambridge

opening quoteOf course! I think it's amazing Peter Jackson managed to make three really good films all in a row. They really deserved it!closing quote
Riellia, 13, Oxford

opening quoteNo way! I didn't even like the film.closing quote
Abi, 10, Marlow

opening quoteI was pleased but I think that other films like Pirates of the Caribbean and Master and Commander should have won more than they did - it would have made it much fairer.closing quote
Jack, 12, Barnsley

opening quoteThe academy knows nothing about great acting, and just because Johnny Depp (the best actor in the world) played a comic role in Pirates of the Caribbean he still definitely was the BEST ACTOR!!! Johnny Depp should have won the Oscar!!!closing quote
Elizabeth, 14, Texas, USA

opening quoteDefinitely! It's a breath taking film, well worthy of 11 Oscars!closing quote
Tesni, 14, Somerset

opening quoteI think it deserved the Best Picture and Director awards, but seriously, eleven Oscars? There were other, more deserving films in at least three of the categories.closing quote
Eddy, 15, Blackburn

opening quoteNo because there were better films and the film was too long - but it was good and I am happy it won.closing quote
Kash, 14, Rochdale

opening quoteNo, it didn't deserve 11 Oscars. It deserved more!closing quote
Tammy, 15, Oxford

opening quoteDefinitely. LOTR has to be one of the BEST films in cinema history. There was no doubt in my mind that ROTK wouldn't achieve the unbelievable because that is what the film is...UNBELIEVABLE! Now we wait for the Hobbit!closing quote
Dee, 14, Essex

opening quoteI think LOTR got too many awards as many other films deserved them.closing quote
Scott, 14, Fordingbridge

opening quoteNo, I think LotR is the most overrated movie ever and it's ruining chances of other movies getting awards. What's so fun about watching a couple of men in cloaks running about in the muddy rain??closing quote
Hannah, 13, Newcastle

opening quoteOf course it should have. Peter Jackson should've got Best Director every year!!! LOTR will be my fave film 4eva! It really is the one film to rule them all, and one director bound them!!!closing quote
Laura, 13, Launceston

opening quoteYes! They worked so hard over the last four years, and now to receive such a wonderful honour at the Oscars is unbelievable! I couldn't have been happier!closing quote
Latasha, 14, USA

opening quoteOf course! I was so happy, Pete lives just a couple of blocks away! I haven't met him but we're still all pretty hyped bout it. I went to the ROTK world premiere parade and shook Ian McKellen's hand!closing quote
Annie, 14, Wellington, NZ

opening quoteYes it did! Well done LOTR. It definitely deserved all 11, and more!closing quote
Sarah, 15, Basingstoke

opening quoteDefinitely. Best films ever made. Peter Jackson rox. Go, New Zealand!closing quote
Kylee, 15, New Zealand

opening quoteYay! I'm so so so so so so so happy! Go da kiwi! I think LOTR deserved every single thing it won!closing quote
Lizzy, 13, New Zealand

opening quoteAbsolutely. I think the other LOTR films should have won 11 Oscars too.closing quote
Ali, 12, Bristol



More InfoBORDER=0
Find OutGuide to the Oscars
ChatChat about films
QuizTry our Oscars

BORDER=0

Past StoriesBORDER=0
Hollywood ready for Oscar night
Rings named best film at Baftas
Shock award win for Johnny Depp
Oscar nomination for 13 year old

BORDER=0


 


E-mail this page to a friend



Full Chat Section
Also in Your Comments now:
Your views on forced marriages
Your messages for Paula Radcliffe
What did you do for bonfire night?
Who influences you the most? Vote: who influences you the most?
Today's quickfire quiz How well do you know today's news?
Win a Haunted Mansion goody bag!
Play Rings Slider Challenge Play our tricky Rings Slider game!
Guides A-Z
A clickable list of all our guides
© BBC Back to top^^
Homepage | UK | World | Sport | Music | TV/Film | Animals | Sci/Tech | Weather
Pictures | Find Out | The Team | Games | Chat | Vote | Win | Quiz | Club