Top of the Pop producer says he hates S Club Juniors and doesn't want them on the show.
So are bands like this top of the flops? Or do you love them anyway?
Send us your thoughts using the form below.
We are no longer taking e-mails on this topic. Please scroll down to read what you had to say...
I think the juniors r wicked.
Rhona, 9, Marchington
I 100% agree with the TOTP producer. I wouldn't let them on my show in a million years.
I think S Club Juniors are the best band around!!!! Me and my best m8 are their number one fans!!!!!!!!!!! I love Calvin to bits.
Louise, 11, Leicester
Although people criticize them for being so young, I like the Juniors. I usually listen to rock music, but I think that they appeal to kids because they are young.
Charlie, 13, Southampton
S Club Juniors suck, I can't believe they're a real band and anyone would ever sign them!! These days, record companies look for so much more than people who can sing. They want an extra talent, like songwriting, producing, or playing an instrument. Cheesy pop groups are OUT!!
The SCJ are quite cool. They sing well but need to work on not being so nevous on stage. I think Hannah is quite cool. They would appeal to young teenagers and young school kids and even 16-year-olds!