BBC News Online: Education

Nursery curriculum 'too much too soon'

They argue that the proposed "early learning goals" are too formal, and will lower standards and damage children's development.

Sixteen of the government's 18 Early Excellence Centres, set up to highlight the best ways to teach three to five-year-olds, have rejected ministers' draft proposals for nursery education in England.

They say the government is trying to get children to do too much too soon, and is ignoring research which suggests very young children learn best through play.

Julian Grenier of Woodlands Park Nursery in London, one of the government's Early Excellence Centres, said: "Our worry is that many people will look at the goals, and they will think that that's the work they have to do with the young children.

"Even though the goals are for children aged five and above, and they are working with three-year-olds, they might have their sights on the goals, whereas we feel they should have their focus firmly on the child."

In many European countries, the formal curriculum does not begin until the age of six, seven or even eight.

But these proposals would, in effect, introduce a National Curriculm from age three, setting targets for what children should achieve over the two years of nursery education.

The "early learning goals" say that by the end of the reception year, most children should be able to name all the letters of the alphabet, read simple sentences independently, and write sentences, sometimes using punctuation.

Parents at Woodlands agree with the centre's opinion that the goals are too much too soon.

"If they want to splash in mud, and explore what that feels like, I think that's more important than to try and make them sit down and learn to write," said one.

But Education Minister Margaret Hodge said critics had misunderstood the government's intentions.

"What we are really trying to do is make sure that our children at this crucial early stage are ready to learn, ready to develop the crucial literacy and numeracy skills that we want all children to acquire," she told BBC News.

Relevant Stories

Targets for nursery children (19 Feb 99 | Education)
Pre-school (19 May 98 | England and Wales)

Internet Links

Qualifications and Curriculum Authority

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Links to other Education stories