BBC News Online: Education

Education system racist - Ouseley

Sir Herman pointed to the disproportionate level of under-achievement by black children in schools.

The explanation, he told The Times Educational Supplement (TES), was "institutional racism" which was "an inherent part of the education system".

The commission defines institutional racism to mean that the practices and procedures or methods of working of an institution will have a worse impact on one ethnic group than another, whether or not that impact is intended.

Sir Herman's remarks come ahead of next week's publication of the Macpherson inquiry report into the investigation of the racist murder of the black London teenager Stephen Lawrence, and the wider lessons to be learned from the case.

He said: "Why is it that after almost 40 years of analysing and campaigning about this, so many black children are still under-achieving; that there are so few ethnic minority teachers; that bodies like Ofsted are so lacking in ethnic minority input?

"Many organisations have good intentions and excellent paper policies and many individuals try very hard, but the end result is still the same."

Sir Herman was responding to comments made by Althea Efunshile, Director of Education and Community Services in Lewisham, south London.

She told parents in Hackney, east London, this week that under-achievement and high exclusion rates for ethnic-minority children were evidence that racism was as endemic in education as in other public institutions.

Exclusions

The General Secretary of the National Association of Schoolmasters/Union of Women Teachers, Nigel de Gruchy, criticised Sir Herman's remarks.

"Such a blanket condemnation of the system is unjustified and profoundly unhelpful," he said.

"There could be other factors at play here, such as poverty. You might get similar results by comparing poor whites with well-to-do whites."

Statistics show no difference between the levels of attainment with which black and white children start school. But a gap widens by secondary school.

And black young men are three times as likely to be permanently excluded (expelled) from school than their white counterparts - in some areas, the figure is as high as 15%.

Relevant Stories

Boy withdrawn over 'racist' song (22 Jan 99 | Education)
Blunkett targets truancy and expulsions (01 Oct 98 | Education)
Schools 'hiding racism' (08 Jul 98 | Education)
Britain is racist, say pupils (29 Jun 98 | Education)

Internet Links

CRE (site soon to be relaunched)
TES
Education department consultation on social inclusion
Social Exclusion Unit

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Links to other Education stories