BBC NEWS    BBC Sport >>   Graphics version >>   Change to UK edition >>
News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health | Talking Point
UK News Contents: England | N Ireland | Scotland | Wales | Politics | Education
Monday, 20 May, 2002, 16:57 GMT 17:57 UK

Immigrants 'are political scapegoats'

Race groups are blaming government immigration policy for some of the negative perceptions highlighted in a BBC News Online survey.

The survey showed that 47% of white people felt immigration had harmed British society.

Mike Rahman of the National Union of Refugee Organisations said he believed the government encouraged such negative images.

"Politicians feed on this because they need explanations as to why there's a shortage of housing and low standards in public services.

"The government needs to take responsibility for telling people the truth about the lack of services and not use refugees or immigrants as a scapegoat for their failed policies."


" We need to deal with racism so it's good to see most people acknowledging it exists - it vindicates our position "

Habib Rahman, JCWI

Home Secretary David Blunkett's recent remarks about asylum seekers' children "swamping" schools had been a very racist statement which had not helped the situation, Mr Rahman added.

Alasdair Mackenzie of Asylum Aid told BBC News Online any hope of improvement in the perception of immigrants lay with the government.

The right presentation of asylum seekers could totally change perceptions, Mr Mackenzie said.

"Kosovan refugees were welcomed with open arms by local communities because the government was taking a lead and saying 'these are people we should help' .

"But equally you get asylum seekers from other parts of the world where they don't know what's happening and there's a very hostile message coming across from the government."

Health workers

Don de Silva of the 1990 Trust said there was a need to make people in Britain more aware of the contribution of immigrants over the years.

"If there were no health workers from the black and ethnic minority communities the health sector would be in a very poor state," Mr de Silva said.

Three quarters of those questioned for BBC News Online's survey said they backed the government's plan to force all immigrants to learn English.


" If there were no health workers from the black and ethnic minority communities the health sector would be in a very poor state "

Don de Silva
1990 Trust

Habib Rahman of the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants said that was a worrying finding.

"No-one in their right minds would oppose people learning the main language of the country - it's in their own interest," Mr Rahman said.

But not everyone was able to learn, he added.

"If you ask people whether somebody who perhaps because of old age or a disability is not able to learn, whether they should then be deprived of their rights, I think the majority would say that would be completely wrong."

Positive developments

But Mr Rahman said he was encouraged that more than half of those questioned believed Britain was a racist society.

"We need to deal with racism so it's good to see most people acknowledging it exists - it vindicates our position," Mr Rahman said.

Don de Silva of the 1990 Trust also saw positive developments in the poll findings.

"It's good the survey has identified that more than half of those questioned have someone from a different ethnic minority background in their immediate circle of friends.

"That is a positive thing and there appears to be a much greater move towards understanding than there has been before."

But the finding that a third of black and Asian people felt racism had hindered their job prospects was a big worry, Mr de Silva added.

Immigration clampdown

The survey on race in the UK came as Prime Minister Tony Blair called for asylum and immigration to be put at the top of the agenda of a European Union summit in Seville next month.

Speaking after talks with the Spanish Prime Minister at Downing Street on Monday, Mr Blair said robust regulations were needed to secure European borders.

He wants to use the EU's financial clout to punish countries where asylum seekers are coming from.

"We're not advocating a 'fortress Europe,' but what we are saying is there's got to be some order and some rules brought into the system whereby people come into Europe," he said.

A Home Office spokeswoman said that would study the survey findings but the government was committed to making the UK a "successful multi-racial society where equality of opportunity if a reality for all."

Home Office evidence suggested migrants contributed more to the UK economy than they took in benefits.

"The government is therefore taking steps to ensure that people with skills and talents the UK needs are able to come into the UK on a sensible and managed basis," she said.


Related to this story:
EU signals asylum action (20 May 02 | UK Politics) Britain 'a racist society' - poll (20 May 02 | UK) BBC Race Survey: What it reveals (19 May 02 | UK) Immigration shake-up unveiled (07 Feb 02 | UK Politics) UK's anti-racism policies 'failing' (23 Feb 02 | UK) Blunkett urges citizenship debate (11 Dec 01 | UK Politics)


Internet links: Asylum Aid | Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants | Black Information Network (1990 Trust) |
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

^^ Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | Feedback | ©