BBC News Online: UK

Hindley 'has not served long enough'

David Pannick QC said the 32 years she had served was not long enough for such a "pitiless" killer.

Hindley, 56, is asking the Court of Appeal to overrule the decision of successive home secretaries to deny her parole.

Her lawyers say the imposition of a "whole life" tariff is against natural justice since the trial judge recommended she serve 30 years.

Shocking crimes

But Mr Pannick said: "The passage of time - 32 years - cannot erase the truly horrific conduct with which this appellant was found guilty."

He rejected claims by Hindley that she was the victim of "intimidation and corruption" by her co-defendant Ian Brady, now 60.

Mr Pannick said: "The Secretary of State simply does not accept that the account now given by the appellant, even if true, provides mitigation which could reduce the proper tariff below that of whole life."

Hindley, who was convicted of killing 10-year-old Lesley Ann Downey and Edward Evans, 17, is held at Highpoint Prison in Suffolk. She has subsequently admitted playing a part in the murders of Keith Bennett, 12, and Pauline Reade, 16.

Their victims were buried on Saddleworth Moor, on the edge of the Peak District overlooking Manchester.

'Murder under duress'

Hindley's lawyer, Edward Fitzgerald QC, said on Monday she had been throttled and raped by Brady and her family had been threatened.

Mr Pannick said Hindley's part in the murders of Lesley Anne Downey and Edward Evans was "pitiless".

She helped lure them to their deaths, he said, and had earlier assisted Brady to dispose of the body of John Kilbride, 10.

Mr Pannick said: "This is not a case where someone has forced her at knife point, or whatever, to carry out that specific act."

Last year the Court of Appeal, led Lord Chief Justice Bingham rejected her lawyers' arguments.

'Life means life'

The three judges ruled that home secretaries had the power to decide that a life sentence can mean life.

But, allowing her leave to challenge their ruling, he did not rule out that one day Hindley could be released "in exceptional circumstances".

The case has repercussions for many of Britain's most notorious killers. Rose West, Dennis Nilsen and Peter Sutcliffe are among those who have also been told they will never be freed.

The appeal continues.

Relevant Stories

Hindley 'should never be released' (07 Oct 98 | UK)
Keep Hindley in jail, says ex-lover Brady (27 Aug 98 | UK)
Hindley's new evidence in fight for freedom (15 Aug 98 | UK)
Court tells Hindley life means life (18 Dec 97 | UK)

Internet Links

Home Office
HM Prison Service

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Next steps for peace
Blairs' surprise over baby
Bowled over by Lord's
Beef row 'compromise' under fire
Hamilton 'would sell mother'
Industry misses new trains target
Quins fightback shocks Cardiff (From Sport)
Vodafone takeover battle heats up (From Business)
IRA ceasefire challenge rejected
Thousands celebrate Asian culture
Christie could get two-year ban (From Sport)
Colleagues remember Compo (From Entertainment)
Mother pleads for baby's return
Toys withdrawn in E.coli health scare
Nurses role set to expand (From Health)
Israeli PM's plane in accident
More lottery cash for grassroots
Pro-lifers plan shock launch
Double killer gets life
Cold 'cure' comes one step closer (From Health)
Straw on trial over jury reform (From UK Politics)
Tatchell calls for rights probe into Mugabe
Ex-spy stays out in the cold
Blair warns Livingstone (From UK Politics)
Smear equipment `misses cancers' (From Health)
Boyzone star gets in Christmas spirit (From Entertainment)
Fake bubbly warning
Murder jury hears dead girl's diary
Germ warfare fiasco revealed (From UK Politics)
Blair babe triggers tabloid frenzy
Tourists shot by mistake
A new look for News Online