Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | High Graphics | AudioVideo | Feedback | Help | Noticias | Newyddion |
BBC Sport>> High Graphics | BBC SPORT>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo |
UK Contents: England | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales |

BBC News Online: UK


Thursday, 26 April, 2001, 20:59 GMT 21:59 UK

Spies have 'no right to disclose secrets'


Annie Machon and David Shayler
New human rights legislation does not give former spies the right to disclose state secrets, a court was told on Thursday.

Former MI5 agent David Shayler was in the High Court accused of breaching the Official Secrets Act by passing information to a Sunday newspaper.

But a defiant Mr Shayler said he was going to "put the British state on trial".

Mr Shayler, 35, was in court with his girlfriend and ex-MI5 agent Annie Machon, and members of his family.



We plan to subpoena Jack Straw and Robin Cook
David Shayler

He claimed that in the 1970s agents tapped the telephone of former Northern Ireland Secretary Peter Mandelson and kept a file on Jack Straw, now Home Secretary, but then a left-wing activist.

Arguing he is a genuine "whistleblower" exposing wrongdoing, Mr Shayler will claim his prosecution under the Official Secrets Act is incompatible with the Human Rights Act, which protects free speech.

He said: "I have got nothing to fear, but they have everything to fear."

But prosecutor Nigel Sweeney QC told the court it was "preposterous" that the Human Rights Act would make the criminal trial a "voyage of discovery" into untested realms of the law.

It marks the first time the Official Secrets Act has been challenged in this way.

Telephone taps

Mr Shayler, who was born in Middlesbrough and lives in London, says the disclosures, and a number he has made since then which are not subject to the trial, were made to expose incompetence and malpractice in the security services.

Two of the charges relate to unauthorised disclosure of security service information and the third relates to revealing details of telephone taps.

Each carries a maximum sentence of two years. Whatever the outcome of the case, the Shayler affair is expected to have major repercussions on the Official Secrets Act.

Both the prosecution and the defence could take the human rights issue to judicial review, delaying the case for a year or more.

'Optimistic'

Mr Shayler said: "It's obvious that this trial will be put back as a result of this preliminary hearing, possibly to appeal at the House of Lords.

"If it takes place it will take place after the general election.

"We plan to subpoena Jack Straw and Robin Cook and it is quite obvious they don't want to answer questions in open court right before an election."

Mr Shayler was supported by his mother Anne, father Ron and brother Jeremy as he walked into court.

Also present was former Army colonel Nigel Wylde, who was unsuccessfully prosecuted under the Official Secrets Act last year.

David Shayler's girlfriend, Annie Machon
He turned up along with Julie-Ann Davies, a researcher for the satirical programme The Mark Thomas Comedy Product, who was arrested and questioned under the Official Secrets Act because she had been in communication with Mr Shayler.

Intelligence and security expert Professor David Vincent, deputy vice-chancellor of Keele University, said it was the most significant spy trial since that of Clive Ponting in 1985.

Ministry of Defence civil servant Ponting was acquitted of leaking documents which showed Tory ministers had misled the House of Commons about the sinking of the Argentine warship the Belgrano in the Falklands War.


Related to this story:
Shayler faces 'closed door' trial (25 Oct 00 | UK)


Internet links: MI5 |
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | High Graphics | AudioVideo | Feedback | Help | Noticias | Newyddion |
BBC Sport>> High Graphics | BBC SPORT>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo |
UK Contents: England | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales |

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©