Lenovo tops eco-friendly ranking

Compiled by Greenpeace, the quarterly report ranks firms by how green their production processes are and what they do to recycle hardware they sell.

In previous reports Lenovo ranked low for eco-friendliness but in 2007 it scooped the top spot over Nokia, Sony Ericsson, Dell, and Samsung.

Apple came last of the 14 firms Greenpeace profiled in the report.

Action plan

The study, which was first compiled in 2006, looks at how big electronics firms make their hardware to see if they use toxic chemicals in the production process and scrutinises what they do to recycle goods when customers have stopped using them.

The campaigning group said that overall scores for the hi-tech firms it profiled had improved but it shied away from describing any hardware maker as "green".

GREENPEACE RANKINGS

• 1) Lenovo: 8
• 2) Nokia: 7.3
• 3=) Sony/Ericsson: 7
• 3=) Dell: 7
• 5=) Samsung: 6.3
• 5=) Motorola: 6.3
• 7) Fujitsu/Siemens: 6
• 8) Hewlett-Packard: 5.6
• 9) Acer: 5.3
• 10) Toshiba: 4.3
• 11) Sony: 4
• 12=) LG Electronics: 3.6
• 12=) Panasonic: 3.6
• 14) Apple: 2.7

Top of the table Lenovo, which bought IBM's consumer electronics division in 2005, got 8 out of 10 for offering takeback services in all the nations where its products are sold. This means it will recycle any broken or obsolete own-brand product returned to it.

"Given the growing mountains of e-waste in China - both imported and domestically generated - it is heartening to see a Chinese company taking the lead, and assuming responsibility at least for its own branded waste," said Ms Kruszewska.

However, Lenovo lost marks for still using some of the most toxic substances to make its products.

Other firms in the top five, such as Sony-Ericsson, have already eliminated toxic chemicals including brominated fire retardants, polyvinyl chloride, beryllium and phthalates from their factories.

Greenpeace criticised Apple for not setting a deadline for eliminating some toxic chemicals from its production processes. Apple scored 2.7 out of 10 on Greenpeace's ranking.

In response, Apple said in a statement: "We disagree with Greenpeace's rating and the criteria."

The company added: "Apple has a strong environmental track record and has led the industry in restricting and banning toxic substances such as mercury, cadmium and hexavalent chromium, as well as many brominated flame retardants."

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
Greenpeace
Greenpeace report on electronics firms
Lenovo
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites