High Graphics | BBC Sport>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo | High Graphics | BBC SPORT>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo |
Talking Point Contents: Forum |

BBC News Online: Talking Point


Friday, 9 November, 2001, 12:17 GMT

Harry Potter: Craze or classic?


One of the most-eagerly awaited movies in years, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone, has received its world première in London's Leicester Square

The film's released later this week worldwide, is widely expected to be among the most successful ever made.

JK Rowling, the author of the Potter books, said she was "happy and relieved" by how faithful the film is to her creation.

Have you seen the film or read the books - what do you think? Will children be reading them in years to come? Is Harry Potter the latest craze or major classic?

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your emails below.


Craze or classic - who cares? Harry's adventures has kept me amused on many a boring train journey to work. Can't wait for the next one to come out!
Heather, UK



The Potter storiesstood out long before the hype started
Liam, UK

Harry Potter will probably make "classic" status in enough time. Although it is mostly being driven by the whole Hollywood marketing machine at the moment, the Potter stories actually stood out and became successful long before the hype started. They will continue to be successful long after the hype has died down.
Liam, UK

Why all the comparisons with Lord of the Rings? It wasn't written for children, was it? It's too long, pretentious and tedious for an adult to appreciate, let alone a child!
Tony Cairns, UK

I'm interested to see how the Lord of the Rings film does alongside HP. My only concern is that after HP, LOTR will be judged by the same yardstick. In my mind they are both classics in their own right. There is nothing subversive about either of them.
Edward Buckingham, France

JK Rowling does not even come close to the writings of such as Tolkein and Lewis. Obviously those who think that have never read beyond grade-school level!
KC, USA



We all need some escapism from the hard realities of this crazy world we live in
Simon UK, England

It says a lot about the lack of direction and spirituality in our children's lives in the UK at the moment. That there is hyper excitement over some imaginative fiction and release of the film that is some how going to fill the vacuum in our sad lives and make us all live happily ever after! Yet another fad that will pass, exciting at the moment but forgotten in no time? However we all need some escapism from the hard realities of this crazy world we live in.
Simon UK, England

I'm worried about all these people who think children are being led down the path to occultism by Harry Potter. The Chronicles of Narnia is a Christian classic and it features loads of blatantly Christian themes wrapped up in magic and the "occult". Then of course, I hesitate to mention the vast number of references to magical events in that great mythological work known as the "Bible". Talk about subversive!
LD, Cambridge, UK

Harry Potter is just a craze nothing more. Look at Pokeman that was a craze but has more or less gone quiet now.
Daniel, UK

Classic or Craze, it does not matter to me for my four boys are driving me crazy talking about it the whole time.
Arif Sayed, Dubai,UAE



There is someone for everyone to relate to - good or bad
Aimee, USA

Yes, it will become a classic. It teaches life challenges in the same manner as Disney stories, without Prince Charming or Snow White. There is someone for everyone to relate to - good or bad.
Aimee, USA

Last week people wanted to ban Halloween and now you are saying that Harry Potter will lead kids astray. Are kids not allowed to have fun anymore? I think encouraging children to read is good. The magic in Harry Potter is harmless fun. It is not encouraging kids to turn into witches. In fact the Wicca faith doesn't believe in allowing children to join. You can't join until you are old enough to make an informed decision when you are 18 and are an adult.
Rachel H, UK

Harry Potter is definitely not a classic & the medias' comparisons of it to The Lord of the Rings are beyond ludicrous. However, at least it maybe inspiring a new generation of kids to read instead of playing console games & sniffing lighter fuel
Martin, London, UK



No, it's not a classic yet

Matt, Manchester, UK

No, it's not a classic yet - our good friend hindsight will decide whether it becomes one or not. However, reading some of these messages from the doom and gloomers, I must say I think it's fantastic that at last this country is starting to embrace different philosophies and angles on spirituality. We really do underestimate children's abilities to decide for themselves what works for them on an individual level.
Matt, Manchester, UK

Harry Potter is most definitely a classic. JK Rowling is an amazing author - she never fails to deliver excitement, page after page.
William, Hale, Cheshire

Ask me again in 50 years time.
Andy W, UK

Characters we can identify with and interesting, sometimes surprising, plots are the basic ingredients of good 'classic' literature the world over. The Wonderful World of Oz or Enid Blyton spring to my mind. J.K. Rowling's stories being imaginative, novel, well-written and rivetting have those same ingredients. They are already modern classics - and not just for children.
CJ Lehmann, Germany



A classic is something which is bought but never read! Harry Potter is certainly not that.
Andy, England

A classic is something which is bought but never read! Harry Potter is certainly not that. It is an awe inspiring tale, which creates as much suspense as any Ian McEwan.
Andy, England

It certainly is classic, and that's why it had such a success. I think the Harry Potter series will change the children current obsession with the robots and pokemons and draw them into a whole new world of litriture.
Yahya, Christchurch, New Zealand

I find it absolutely terrifying that this type of occultism is being encouraged. Our children's minds should be protected from this tripe.
Rev Paul Mason, UK

If the Rev Paul Mason is so horrified by supernatural issues, then why is he a Man of The Cloth? It seems to me that Harry Potter is far less likely to cause havoc than religion does, and both have been founded on the concept and basis of paranormal events. The fact that Harry Potter is possibly doing better trade than the Rev Mason couldn't be an issue here, could it?
Chris B., England



A lot of what we call classics now were thought to lead people 'down the false path'
Joe Lozon, Canada

You know, a lot of what we call classics now were thought to lead people 'down the false path'. The Harry Potter Series is seldom about magic and never once is the occult mentioned. It is more about Friendship, Loyalty, Love, Compassion, and Courage. Anyone who does not want children to think about these things or to develop any of them is afraid of lossing the little control they have over a young mind. A mind is meant to grow and evolve, not be put out.
Joe Lozon, Canada

It certainly is classic, and that's why it had such a success. I think the Harry Potter series will change the children current obsession with the robots and pokemons and draw them into a whole new world of litriture.
Yahya, Christchurch, New Zealand

It is a classic. No doubt about it. JK Rowling's writing is so thoughtful and imaginative. It appeals to adults as well as children and no one can doubt that the magic of JK Rowling's writing is capturing the hearts of millions.
Jennifer, Northern Ireland



Escapist moments, dollops of humanity, delicious slices of Brit life and whimsey, and small heroes against formidable odds
Don Weinstein, US

In the US, we are anxiously awaiting your new British invasion - one of English literature brought to life. Both Harry Potter and the Lord of the Rings will bring out exactly what we need today: escapist moments, dollops of humanity, delicious slices of Brit life and whimsey, and small heroes against formidable odds. Bravo! No wonder the Salem witches were exonerated....just in time.
Don Weinstein, US

Classic or no classic, I kind of want to read it now.... I feel I'm missing out on something here!
James Blair, UK

As an aspiring writer myself I have untold admiration for JK Rowling. She is not only a super writer but she has an edge and I like her style, I can only wish that I could see the faces of the literary agents that turned her down as they do most of us without any meaningful comments. Eat your hearts out chums. Craze or classic Harry Potter should be around for many years to come. I only wish that dear old Tom Sharpe was still at it!
Alan, Poland

Neither. Just plain stupid! Cannot believe why there is so much fuss about this film. It looks like yet another result of the massive hyping process.
Shankar Krishnamoorthy, USA



Kids don't need to be 'led' to believe in magic and fantasy - it's intrinsic to childhood
Sarah C, UK

Classic? Maybe. Hyped? Yes, but even classics get that treatment when the film comes out. But dangerous? No, no, a thousand times no! Kids don't need to be 'led' to believe in magic and fantasy - it's intrinsic to childhood, unless do-gooders try to brainwash it out of them. You have to ask what these people's motives are, and Tolkien put it best - that the only people opposed to escape are jailers....
Sarah C, UK

It's too early to rate them as classics, yet. Only time will show. I do think that they are over-hyped, but if people like them, why not.
Peter, Finland

Harry Potter is far from a classic. It is probably a classic case of leading children to be obsessed with the spectacular and paranormal. Be warned that dabbling with things magical on this scale could bring a great judgement to the peoples of the world.
RJ Brown, UK

James Ike and RJ Brown take note: The Hogwarts students are banned from using their powers outside of school till they reach adulthood and understand what their power means. Far from encouraging occultism, it emphasises the ramifications of using any such powers.
Tim Staddon, UK

RJ Brown - riddikulus!
Anne, UK

RJ Brown is obviously one of the Dursley's
M Maclean, USA



Harry Potter can be used as a recruitment tool for the occult
James Ike, USA

They are definitely not classics when compared to Lion, Witch and the Wardrobe by CS Lewis. The witch there was evil. Harry Potter can be used as a recruitment tool for the occult and parents and kids are duped by it.
James Ike, USA

To see a real, bona-fide classic, wait until December for the first instalment of "The Lord Of The Rings" - perhaps the Potter-mania will be set into sharp relief when compared to something of undoubted substance and quality.
Tim McNulty, Isle Of Man

November 5th. 2015. Harry who...?
Chris B, England



At least it has gotten children reading again
Akki, UK

Whether it is a classic or a craze doesn't really matter, but it is impossible to tell if it's a classic yet. In ten years time you could say yes but not now. At least it has gotten children reading again instead of watching the TV all the time
Akki, UK

I am not sure whether Harry Potter is a classic. As others have said only time will tell. However, it does seem that the whole Harry Potter phenomena has benefited from enormous media hype aimed at generating massive amounts of revenue from children. It will be interesting to see how Harry Potter stands up at the box office next month against Lord of the Rings, which is widely regarded as a timeless classic of appeal to all age groups.
R Watson, Manchester, UK

It's either a classic craze or a crazy classic.
TJ Cassidy, USA

I'm not pedantically qualified to give an expert critique. But, I do know it's made a lot of people happy, and it's been a marketing success. What more of a yardstick is needed?
Tom, Australia



The current commercially- fuelled enthusiasm for all things Potter is certainly a craze, but the hype is founded on something much more enduring
Alice Stainer, UK

The current commercially- fuelled enthusiasm for all things Potter is certainly a craze, but the hype is founded on something much more enduring. The label 'classic' is a dubious one because it is open to multiple interpretation, but the Potter ingredients fit my own definition: a meticulously realised 'other' (but curiously recognisable) world; intelligently observed characters between which there is complex and often touching interaction; and importantly, a reassuringly sound moral core, all delivered in well-executed prose. I find the same in the 'classics' of Ransome, Lewis and Tolkein I enjoyed as a child.
Alice Stainer, UK

"Classic" is a term that usually means something has held or increased its worth over a period of time. 100 years from now the answer will be self-evident.
Jane, USA



Of course Harry Potter's a craze but what a fun craze it is
Martin Law, UK

Of course Harry Potter's a craze but what a fun craze it is. Every now and again people need something to distract them from the current negative global events that they can do nothing about except worry. In a short time, just like Star Wars, ET and Pokemon, Harry will disappear and be taken over by something else. Only time will tell whether or not Harry will re-emerge as another Alice in Wonderland.
Martin Law, UK

I don't think HP's got the makings of a classic, but at least the stories are infinitely more enjoyable than the hugely over-rated Lord of the Rings and Narnia Chronicles. HP's also far preferable to much of the contemporary teen junk my 14 year old daughter and her friends read.
Alex Cutelli, UK



Enough with the Harry Potter already!
Paul, UK

Enough with the Harry Potter already! I've got it at home with my kids, I've got it on the radio, I've got it on the TV, I've got it in the newspapers. I have even got it at work. AArrgghhh is there no escape?
Paul, UK

JK Rowling will be remembered alongside JRR Tolkien and CS Lewis as one of the great children's authors of all time.
Guy Hammond, England

In 20 odd years time, sad 30-somethings will be sitting around at parties going "hey, do you remember Harry Potter?" in the same way sad 30-somethings now go on about The Clangers or Bagpuss.
Antony, UK

Harry Potter is something different, a fantasy land for children and adults. Good clean entertainment with nice humour. I think that it will have enduring appeal for many years to come.
Owen Jones, UK

R.J. Brown should remember that Harry Potter is a fictional character intended for children (though also enjoyed by adults!) and along with his adventures should be accepted as such. If you are worried about the supernatural, there are worse things in this world to be worried about and misinformed judgement is one of them!
Jim, UK

Harry Potter is the same old kids nonsense dressed up in new clothes - absence of parents, boarding school, fatness as the sin above all other - all of these can be found in Enid Blyton. Kids will be reading Harry Potter for years, just as they read Blyton, but that doesn't make it a classic. It's just good fun and escapism - which RJ Brown would realise if he were living in the same universe as most other people.
Karen Dixon, UK

Harry Potter is a fantastic piece of literature and will thrill both children and grown-ups for many years to come. RJ Brown, one of my favourite sayings is "paralysis by over-analysis". Just enjoy!
Charlotte Ives, UK



Internet Links:
Internet links: Harry Potter |
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
High Graphics | BBC Sport>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo | High Graphics | BBC SPORT>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo |
Talking Point Contents: Forum |

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©