BBC News Online: Special Report

UK moves towards national policy on NHS drugs

Who gets the medicine? NHS funds are not limitless and the rising cost of medical progress is increasingly forcing this question onto the health agenda.

Until now doctors and health authorities have had to make decisions on whether they can afford new drugs, leading to accusations that their availability depends on where you live.

Decisions should be based on clinical issues and not just cost, but there are suspicions that decisions are often dictated by budgets.

Health Secretary Frank Dobson's decision to impose a temporary ban on Viagra based on its cost is effectively the first step towards the creation of a national policy on drug availability on the NHS.

National guidance

Mr Dobson said the anti-impotence drug would not be available on the NHS until his team of ministers had consulted "further expert guidance" over the cost of treatment.

The Department is expected to issue strict guidelines defining exactly who gets the drug and who is allowed to prescribe it.

The DoH has long denied that rationing exists in the NHS.

But now health ministers accept that the plethora of costly modern medicines available put the NHS at risk, a spokesman said.

He added: "In the longer term, we are putting together plans for the National Institute of Clinical Excellence [to decide which drugs should be available on the NHS] so we do not have medicine by postcode."

Ensuring clinical need

He said "substantive guidance" would be issued to ensure that those with a real clinical need got Viagra.

The Institute will assess all new drugs in this way when it becomes operational in the next two years or so.

Angela Coulter, of the King's Fund health research body, said the government approach was refreshing and she hoped it would extend to other drugs.

A spokeswoman for the British Medical Association said the move was welcome.

"We believe that rationing decisions, if they have to be made, should not be made in the consulting room.

"They should be made at a national level."

She added: "It is quite a dramatic moment in the history of the NHS because, up until now, as soon as a drug was licensed it was available on the NHS."

The BMA hopes the guidance will be specific enough to remove this burden from doctors. "If the guidelines say A, B, C, D, E and your patients do not fall into all those categories, then you can turn to your patient with a clear conscience and say no."

The government's announcement is an acknowledgement that priorities have to be set.

Expensive treatments

However, the Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry attacked the witholding of any treatment at a national level.

It pointed to evidence suggesting that expensive treatments are cost-effective in the long term.

The Association's study showed that a £3,600 course for hepatitis C could cure the disease in a quarter of all cases.

If left untreated, hospitalisation and other costs escalated to more than £50,000 per patient.

Controversy has long surrounded the availability of expensive new drugs on the NHS.

The multiple sclerosis treatment beta-interferon, which costs approximately £10,000 per patient per year, has proven benefits for some MS sufferers.

In 1995, the NHS Executive issued guidelines for prescribing beta-interferon, but doctors and patients claimed the advice was too vague.

This allowed health authorities to set local guidelines, and refuse to pay for the treatment.

Relevant Stories

Viagra firm hits out at Dobson (15 Sep 98 | Viagra)
Europe says yes to Viagra (15 Sep 98 | Viagra)
The cost of being healthy (01 Jul 98 | Special report)

Internet Links

Department of Health
The NHS Executive
Multiple Sclerosis Society of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Viagra 'limited to cut cost'
Viagra action 'legally indefensible'
More men to get NHS Viagra
Keep on prescribing Viagra, doctors told
Women can benefit from Viagra (From Health)
NHS bosses: Restrict Viagra
'Give impotent men Viagra'
Clubbers taking Viagra cocktail
'Stop Viagra mail shots'
Viagra impotence warning
Viagra patients could sue, says doctor
Doctors rebel against 'cruel' Viagra rules
Viagra risks unproven
Viagra: The rationing precedent (From Health)
Fast-acting Viagra spray developed
GPs issue 10-day deadline on Viagra (From Health)
Viagra attracts £338m in six months
Dogs mutilated in Viagra test
Viagra ban backed by GPs
Doctors: Why we oppose Viagra rationing