High Graphics | BBC SPORT>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo |
World Contents: Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia | From Our Own Correspondent | Letter From America |

BBC News Online: World: South Asia


Tuesday, 2 April, 2002, 16:39 GMT 17:39 UK

GM crops win new friends


Cotton pickers
GM cotton has been approved for use in India
By Alex Kirby
News Online's Environment Correspondent

Genetically modified (GM) crops have taken a big step towards wider public acceptance this week.

India announced on 26 March that it had approved the use of a type of GM cotton for commercial production.

The biotechnology industry believes it is poised to persuade consumers that they have nothing to fear.


" Small cotton farmers in India there have been vociferous in saying no to GM crops - they think it'll mean they're simply handed over to Monsanto and the rest of the industry "
Peter Riley, Friends of the Earth

But the opponents of GM crops say they still have everything to fight for.

Last week's decision is important because India has been reluctant to accept the new technology.

It is the world's third largest producer of cotton, after China and the US. But it has had to compete with them despite the handicap of low productivity - something it hopes the GM strain will help to resolve.

This year, about 71% of the US cotton crop will come from GM plants, up 2% on 2001.

In China the area of GM cotton sown rose from 2,000 hectares (5,000 acres) in 1997 to around 700,000 hectares (1,700,000 acres) in 2000.

GM crops in the developing world

Although cotton is sometimes used for animal feed, it is not something people eat - and anti-GM campaigners say that is a crucial difference which should give the industry pause for thought.

Pete Riley, of Friends of the Earth in the UK, told BBC News Online: "It is not a foregone conclusion that developing countries will accept GM varieties as food crops, especially as they may not be as well adapted to local conditions as existing strains.

"In any case, there's still huge opposition in India.

"Small cotton farmers there have been vociferous in saying no to GM crops - they think it'll mean they're simply handed over to Monsanto and the rest of the industry."

Another country which has hesitated over biotechnology is Brazil, but an imminent court ruling there could open the way for the planting of GM soya beans.

World hunger

One of the proudest boasts of the industry is that it has found a way to tackle world hunger. There is far more to ensuring that malnourished people get fed than simply growing more food.


" To deny desperate, hungry people the means to control their futures by presuming to know what is best for them is not only paternalistic but morally wrong "
Hassan Adamu, Nigerian Environment Minister

But there are those who say that GM technology looks much more attractive if your stomach is empty, and that it may have a part to play.

Nigeria's Environment Minister, Hassan Adamu, says: "To deny desperate, hungry people the means to control their futures by presuming to know what is best for them is not only paternalistic but morally wrong."

A book published last year, Seeds of Contention: World Hunger And The Global Controversy Over GM Crops, develops the argument.

It was written by Dr Per Pinstrup-Andersen, director general of the International Food Policy Research Institute (Ifpri), and Ebbe Schioler, an agricultural development consultant.

They say: "Heated public debate threatens to drown out all serious consideration of the important promise genetic engineering has for the poor and hungry in developing countries."

They recognise that the biotechnology industry will need "some sort of ownership protection" if it is to invest in research.

But they say this need not be "the form of blanket protection provided by patents... some more limited arrangement such as the plant variety protection regulations might suffice".


Related to this story:
India allows use of modified cotton (26 Mar 02 | Business) Warning over India GM cotton plan (27 Mar 02 | Business) India nears decision on GM crops (22 Jan 02 | Business) India allows sale of GM cotton (06 Dec 01 | Sci/Tech)


Internet links: Monsanto India | International Food Policy Research Institute | Friends of the Earth | Ministry of the Environment |
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
High Graphics | BBC SPORT>>
Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | AudioVideo |
World Contents: Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia | From Our Own Correspondent | Letter From America |

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©