Tougher bugs beat pesticides

Experts from two major UK agricultural research centres have warned that the speed at which insects are growing resistant to pesticides is outstripping the rate at which new chemical agents can be developed.

More than 40% of potential crop yield was already being lost, they said, and this could worsen.

It might be economically impossible to continue producing certain crops in future, they claimed.

Hardy masses

Some insects actually eat crops, while others help spread diseases which attack the plants.

The report, from Rothamsted Research in Hertfordshire and the John Innes Centre in Norwich, said that at least 540 species of insect were now resistant to at least one class of insecticide.

Professor Ian Crute, director of Rothamsted Research, said: "Just as human health is under threat from antibiotic resistance, so crop health is under threat from insecticide resistance.

"The bugs are gaining on us - and our defences are increasingly fragile.

"We need new science-based tools for insect control and without them, our ability to feed ourselves is in jeopardy."

As with the problem of bacterial resistance to antibiotics, it is suggested that over-use of particular classes of insecticides is partly to blame for the rise of more hardy insects.

No options

However, there are also fears that, with manufacturers choosing to discontinue production of certain chemicals, there may be nowhere to turn in the event of a major outbreak of certain crop pests.

An example in the US means than one billion dollars' worth of production of cabbages, sprouts, cauliflower, swede and turnip is at risk from maggot infestation because farmers rely entirely on just one type of insecticide.

Increasingly, a shift to "broad-spectrum" pesticides - more profitable for manufacturers - could mean the extinction of beneficial insects alongside the targeted pests.

The report calls for increased research to find new ways of attacking pests.

The burgeoning popularity of organic farming has fostered the belief that it is possible to farm effectively with far fewer pesticides. However, the report's authors disagree.

Professor Chris Lamb, from the John Innes Centre, said: "Some of the public have a misplaced fear about pesticides and there is a danger we will score an own goal by failing to protect our ability to grow adequate quantities of food.

"Science is providing exciting new opportunities that will, in time, move us beyond pesticides."