BBC News Online: World: Europe

Vatican apologises over holocaust

Monday, March 16, 1998 Published at 19:35 GMT
Front Page | UK | World | Business | Sci/Tech | Sport | Despatches | On Air | Cantonese | Talking Point | Feedback | High Graphics | Help | Site Map |
image: [ Pius XII did not speak out against the Holocaust, say Jews ]
Vatican apologises over holocaust
The Vatican has apologised to Jews on behalf of the entire Roman Catholic community, for failing to speak out against the Nazi holocaust during World War Two.

In his letter accompanying the apology, the Pope said the holocaust remained an indelible stain on the 20th century.

The Vatican's long-anticipated response to the killing of six million Jews was published in Rome on Monday.

The Head of the Vatican Commission, Cardinal Edward Cassidy, said the Vatican's statement amounted to an act of repentance as well as an apology.

The document asks whether persecution was made easier because some Christians held anti-Jewish prejudices.

But it also declares that many people were unaware of Hitler's so-called "final solution".


[ image: width=150]

Pope John Paul has said he hopes the apology will help to heal the wounds of past injustices and misunderstandings between Christians and Jews.

But the document makes no criticism of the Pope of the time, Pius XII, who has been accused by the Jews of pro-German tendencies.

The Vatican mentions that Pius XII saved hundreds of thousands of Jewish lives himself or through his representatives.

But the document fails to explain why Pope Pius never took sides during World War Two by speaking out against the holocaust while it was actually taking place.

The Vatican has always maintained he did everything he could behind the scenes to stop the slaughter.

In the document, the Vatican asks all Christians to meditate upon the catastrophe.

The apology ends by warning that the seeds of anti-Semitism and anti-Judaism must never again be allowed to take root.

American Jews not impressed

The US Jewish community voiced disappointment at the Vatican's statement .

"We are very sad, very disappointed," said Rabbi Leon Klenicki, director of the Department of Interfaith Affairs of the Anti Defamation League.

"The document falls short of the mark, it's taking a step backward," Rabbi Klenicki said.

The World Jewish Congress (WJC) issued a terse statement saying "those of us engaged in the dialogue have not yet succeeded."

Its statement "does not compare favourably with the French Catholic Bishops' Conference or the German Catholic Bishops' Conference," WJC executive director Elan Steinberg said.

National churches have admitted error

Catholic Bishops in France, Germany and Poland admitted they were at fault for their failure to react to Jewish persecution half a century ago.

But it was not until 1965 that the Vatican eliminated the phrase "perfidious Jews" from the liturgy of a Holy Week service.

Since then, relations between the Holy See and the Jewish state have steadily improved.

Pope John Paul II has dedicated much of his near 20-year-old papacy to improving relations with Jews, whom he refers to as "older brothers," after centuries of animosity.


Relevant Stories

Vatican defends Holocaust stance (14 Mar 98 | Despatches)
Vatican urged to open war archives (09 Feb 98 | World)

Internet Links

The Vatican
US Holocaust Museum
Cybrary of the Holocaust

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Russia expels Norwegian 'spies'
Basque peace talks start
Summit cancelled due to Yeltsin illness
Ministers demand duty-free review
Fraud allegations in Armenia election (From Despatches)
Diplomatic efforts over Kosovo continue
Farmers 'covering up' mad cow cases
PM hails beef ban ease
US ambassador in Dublin to step down
French National Front seeks right-wing alliance
Bid to free British hostages in Chechnya fails
No guaranteed representation for minorities in Hungary
Britain could get extra EU funding
Resignation call after Maze murder rejected
Zhirinovsky faces criminal investigation for hooliganism
Bulgarian premier threatens dissident army officers
Ethnic Russians in Latvia demand passport rights
Kurdish party leaders indicted in Turkey
Cargo vessel brings new tools to Mir
Bomb explodes outside Hungarian politician's home
Dutch government coalition party pro-euthansia

World Contents


Front Page | UK | World | Business | Sci/Tech | Sport | Despatches | On Air | Cantonese | Talking Point | Feedback | High Graphics | Help | Site Map |

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©