BBC NEWS    BBC Sport >>   Graphics version >>   Change to UK edition >>
News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health | Talking Point
Wednesday, 29 March, 2000, 09:21 GMT 10:21 UK

Oscars accused of 'apartheid'

Hit film The Sixth Sense's failure to win any Oscars has sparked an outcry in the Indian press.

The country's media claims the film's lack of success in any of the six categories in which it was nominated was due to racism against its director, M Night Shyamalan, who was born in India. "And the Oscar goes to ... apartheid," ran the headline in The Pioneer - echoing a general mood of injustice in the Indian press following the Academy Awards.

Shyamalan - who was born in Madras, but brought up in Philadelphia - was nominated for best director and original screenplay.

Among the cast, 11-year-old Haley Joel Osment was up for supporting actor and Toni Collette for supporting actress.

The movie itself was also a contender for best picture as well as for best editing.

But it left empty-handed as American Beauty romped home with five Oscars.

Ironically, the supernatural thriller starring Bruce Willis has taken more than $290m (£181m) at the US box office - compared to American Beauty's $108m (£67.5m).

Blockbuster

In India, The Pioneer continued: "Who said nothing in this world is in black and white? The Oscars obviously are and they can keep the trophy for lifetime achievement in bringing apartheid to Hollywood."

Elsewhere, an editorial in The Times of India said: "The Sixth Sense, with a headline star in Bruce Willis and stunning box-office returns, had all the trappings of a sure-fire Oscar winner. But the politics aren't right.

"Honour a young Asian who not only does what they do - make a blockbuster with a big American hero - but manages to beat them at their own game too? That isn't sound politics.

"But do we care? Not really. For this kind of racism can't prevail."

It also pointed to the expansion of the Indian film industry - saying Bollywood is growing by 50% compared to Hollywood's 15%.

However, the Indian Express, while upset at the The Sixth Sense's loss, said American insularity was more of a "rational explanation" than outright racism.

"American Beauty just celebrated America better, in all its quirks and angularities," he said.


Related to this story:
American Beauty's Oscar triumph (28 Mar 00 | Oscars 2000) Willis is people's choice (10 Jan 00 | Entertainment) Bad year for Bollywood (03 Jan 00 | South Asia) Hollywood across the ages (22 Mar 00 | Oscars 2000)


Internet links: The Sixth Sense | The Indian Express | The Pioneer | The Oscars | The Times of India | Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences |
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

^^ Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | Feedback | ©