![[ image: width=150]](/olmedia/45000/images/_47270_copy_explorer.jpg)
![image: [ Microsoft face a fine of $1m a day if the court rules against them ]](/olmedia/45000/images/_47270_copy_micr3.jpg)
The US Department of Justice claims Microsoft is ignoring a court order from Federal Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson, to remove its Internet browser, Internet Explorer, from its Windows 95 operating system.
Microsoft say they are complying but have found that removing the browser prevents the operating system from functioning properly.
Courtroom battle
During a pointed exchanged in the US District Court in Washington DC, Microsoft lawyer Richard Urowsky said the company had carefully reviewed Government briefs in deciding how to comply with the judge's order.
But before Mr Urowsky could go on, Judge Jackson interrupted: "What the Government requested is not the same as what I ordered."
Mr Urowsky replied: "I beg to differ with you."
After more discussion, Judge Jackson said firmly: "It is my language and my language alone that is at issue here."
Mr Urowsky said the company had done what the Justice Department suggested, removing all files contained in its Internet Explorer browser, and that was why Windows 95 would not work.
Judge Jackson said repeatedly the company should have looked at his language instead. He finally asked if Microsoft had given any consideration to seeking clarification from him.
"We gave very careful consideration of that," Mr Urowsky replied. But ultimately Microsoft decided to appeal against the order, he added.
The judge is prohibited from modifying his order while it is on appeal.
Windows domination
The Justice Department says that Microsoft is using its 90% market superiority to create a monopoly. The US Government has also accused it of anti-competitive practices.
Since its introduction, free copies of Internet Explorer have been included with editions of Windows 95, helping the company to conquer 40% of the rapidly growing browser market.
Microsoft has fiercely resisted the court's ruling, claiming that no one has a right to tell it what it can and cannot include in its own products.
![[ image: width=150]](/olmedia/45000/images/_47270_Copy_of_gates.jpg)
Bill Gates, who founded Microsoft, says the company is doing more for competition than the Government realises.
"Building the Internet capability into Windows is good for everyone," he said.
"The Internet is bringing lower prices and more competition to a wider range of industries than any convention in the last 100 years."
Initially the company had agreed to offer computer makers an operating system with all browser files removed, but warned that, as a result, the system would not be able to function as designed.
As a second option, Microsoft said that computer makers could also market an older version of Windows 95 without the Internet Explorer component.
But the Government promptly dismissed the options as unsatisfactory and reiterated its conviction that both products could be separated without affecting a computer's functioning.
A spokesperson for the Justice Department said: "Microsoft's position is untenable. The court should end Microsoft's disobedience and bring it into compliance."
Microsoft's dominant position in the software market is also under investigation by Congress as well as a number of US states and the Government has already demanded the right to review every major piece of Microsoft software before it is released onto the market.
The hearing is expected to last two days. Judge Jackson could rule from the bench or issue a written opinion later.
Microsoft Tokyo offices raided
(13 Jan 98 | Business)
Microsoft appeals court ruling
(16 Dec 97 | Business)
Judge rules against Microsoft browser plans
(12 Dec 97 | Sci/Tech)
Browser wars
(12 Dec 97 | Sci/Tech)
Microsoft's critics take aim
(14 Nov 97 | Sci/Tech)
PC makers 'threatened by Microsoft'
(23 Oct 97 | Business)
Microsoft
US Department of Justice
US House of Representatives
Bill Gates writes in Business Week
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
Indonesia signs IMF deal
Factory sales 'to protect jobs'
Judge rejects Microsoft challenge over 'biased' adviser
British unions demand better deal for part-time workers
Red light for privatised trains
Markets get jitters despite Indonesia pact
Decision due on £40m van package
Seven-year director's ban for Venables
Millennium bug could cripple government
(From Sci/Tech)
Dixons customers cash in on sales
Jobless drop worsens skills shortage
Profit warning over ferry passenger lists
Christmas sales down
Inflation down but target missed
Microsoft Tokyo offices raided
Far East woes could hit exporters
Job-cuts ahead for UK finance sectors?