![[ image: width=150]](/olmedia/310000/images/_313463_cash150.jpg)
However, they cut down United States demands for retaliatory sanctions by two-thirds to $191.4m (£120m) - down from more than half a billion dollars.
In their highly-technical 150 page ruling the three WTO experts suggest four ways in which Brussels can bring its import regime in line with international rules.
Senior EU officials have meanwhile confirmed that the union will "comply" with the ruling, but said they would reserve the right to appeal against it.
One Brussels official, though, said the EU had "no intention of dragging this out".
Others pointed to the fact that the WTO team had provided "a legal basis for resolving the dispute".
European officials insist that the WTO panel has approved the principle of its policy, which is to protect African and Caribbean banana producers.
An EU spokesman said: "There is no ruling here that says under WTO rules it is illegal to offer protection to those (Caribbean) producers."
Cutting down
Nevertheless, the US Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky said: "We are pleased that the arbitrators concur with our position that the EU banana regime is WTO-inconsistent and continues to damage the US economy."
The US administration now has 10 days to cut down the original list of products on which it had threatened to impose punitive tariffs.
Goods targetted ranged from Scottish cashmere sweaters to French hand bags, Italian cheese and German coffee makers.
Products that remain on the list will see their prices double in the US.
Peter Scher, America's top negotiator on agriculture matters, said a decision on what products will be removed from the list and what items will be subjected to 100% tariffs will be made within the next few days.
The United States will choose products in an effort to exert maximum political pressure on EU politicians to change their position on the banana barriers, Mr Scher said.
Preferential treatment
The banana row centres on the preferential treatment that the EU gives to banana producers from former African, Caribbean and Pacific colonies at the expense of Latin American growers and their US backers.
The US case was driven by complaints from two US food distributors, Chiquita and Dole, who are know to have made large financial contributions to both parties in Washington.
As the six-year trade battle culminated, the WTO was asked last month to rule on whether the EU had done enough to amend its import regime and on whether retaliatory American sanctions were legitimate.
The EU argued it had changed its import rules to bring them into line with WTO regulations.
UK worries
The size of the sanctions now permitted is negligible compared to the volume of transatlantic trade. However, some industries could be devastated should they be hit.
The Scottish Cashmere industry is one of them.
Jim Thompson, of the Hawick Cashmere Company, said the sanctions would cause major problems for his industry in Scotland.
"The Americans are unaware how polarised the cashmere industry is in the Borders," he said. "It will have catastrophic affects - if this actually goes through we are looking at a thousand jobs in the Borders," he told BBC Radio Scotland.
The US is also engaged in a trade battle over the European Union's ban against American beef raised with growth hormones.
Banana war exposes old trade divisions
(05 Mar 99 | The Economy)
Banana war spreads to beef
(23 Mar 99 | The Economy)
Bending Blair's ear over bananas
(11 Mar 99 | The Economy)
Tension mounts over banana row
(04 Mar 99 | UK Politics)
Banana deal frittered away
(19 Dec 98 | Business)
Going bananas
(10 Nov 98 | The Economy)
World Trade Organisation
United States Trade Representative
European Union
Caribbean Banana Exporters Association
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
Inquiry into energy provider loyalty
Brown considers IMF job
Chinese imports boost US trade gap
No longer Liffe as we know it
The growing threat of internet fraud
House passes US budget
Online share dealing triples
Rate fears as sales soar
Brown's bulging war-chest
Oil reaches nine-year high
UK unemployment falls again
Trade talks deadlocked
US inflation still subdued
Insolvent firms to get breathing space
Bank considered bigger rate rise
UK pay rising 'too fast'
Utilities face tough regulation
CBI's new chief named
US stocks hit highs after rate rise
US Fed raises rates
UK inflation creeps up
Row over the national shopping basket
Military airspace to be cut
TUC warns against following US
World growth accelerates
Union merger put in doubt
Japan's tentative economic recovery
EU fraud costs millions
CBI choice 'could wreck industrial relations'
WTO hails China deal
US business eyes Chinese market
Red tape task force
Websites and widgets
Guru predicts web surge
Malaysia's economy: The Sinatra Principle
Shell secures Iranian oil deal
Irish boom draws the Welsh
China deal to boost economy
US dream scenario continues
Japan's billion dollar spending spree