[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Wednesday, 20 July, 2005, 09:40 GMT 10:40 UK
Appeal Court backs Bluestone plan
Bluestone would comprise lodges, a snow dome and a water park
The decisions to allow the building of a massive holiday development in Pembrokeshire have been backed by the Court of Appeal.

The £60m Bluestone project sparked controversy as part of it will be built in Pembrokeshire Coast National Park.

The watchdog, the Council for National Parks (CNP), which challenged the High Court's decision to allow the scheme, said it was "deeply disappointed".

The developers argued that the 300 lodges would generate much-needed jobs.

A CNP spokeswoman had said the development would "desecrate" the countryside.

Bluestone has now passed every legal, democratic and environmental test laid before it
Bluestone chief executive William McNamara

But the panel of three judges said they unanimously agreed that planning consent granted by the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park authority was legal.

They upheld the earlier High Court ruling in concluding that the authority's planning committee had correctly taken into account economic benefits in granting approval.

The appeal was seen as a test case in establishing the balance between local economic benefit and conservation issues.

Bluestone chief executive William McNamara said: "We are delighted with this unanimous decision which was not unexpected.

"Bluestone has now passed every legal, democratic and environmental test laid before it by two planning committees, 10 statutory advisors, an independent ombudsman, a High Court judge and finally three Lord Justices at the Supreme Court of Appeal.

'Setting a precedent'

"That is seven professional judgements that all bear witness to the propriety of the Bluestone decision and this clears the way for work to begin on this major new holiday village development in the UK."

Mr McNamara added that he would be asking questions about the £100,000 legal costs he said the park authority will face, which will be covered by tax-payers.

Pembrokeshire National Park Authority supported the development, saying it would not cause environmental damage.

But the CNP, the watchdog which monitors development in national parks across Wales and England, had worried about setting a precedent for developments in other parks.

It said the appeal court had "missed an opportunity" to clarify the legal rules for deciding major planning applications in the parks. Ruth Chambers, CNP¿s Head of Policy, said: ¿Allowing the Bluestone holiday village to go ahead has muddied the waters for the public and developers alike".

The CNP called the judgement "deeply disappointing" and said it was considering the possibility of a final appeal to the House of Lords.

The case went to Court of Appeal in June after the CNP was refused permission to appeal against a High Court ruling it lost in December 2004.

Bluestone row reaches key appeal
17 Jun 05 |  South West Wales
Park body's Bluestone appeal bid
17 Jan 05 |  South West Wales
New challenge to holiday village
06 Jan 05 |  South West Wales
Park holiday village plan backed
17 Dec 04 |  South West Wales
Holiday village starts jobs drive
08 Nov 04 |  South West Wales
MP quits over Bluestone fight
28 Apr 04 |  South West Wales
Bellamy backs Bluestone fight
24 Apr 04 |  South West Wales

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific