BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK: Wales
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Monday, 18 September, 2000, 14:01 GMT 15:01 UK
Call for judicial review over census
Crowd scene
To say they are Welsh, people will have to tick the box marked "Other"
Lawyers are trying to get the courts to overturn a decision not to include the Welsh as a separate nationality on the 2001 census.

A member of Cymru Annibynnol (Independent Wales Party) is seeking a judicial review over the lack of a Welsh tick box on next year's census form.

Solicitors are being instructed on behalf of Dewi Prysor, of Llan Ffestiniog, to submit an emergency claim for legal aid to enable him to seek a judicial review.

He said the action was being taken on the grounds of discrimination against the Welsh and breach of the Human Rights Act, which comes into force in British law on October 2.

In the 2001 census, there will be no special box for people to tick in order to classify their nationality as Welsh.

Scottish census difference

Welsh people will only have the option of classifying themselves as British, Irish or Other.

In Scotland, however, people will have the choice of describing themselves as Scottish through a special tick box which the Scottish Parliament has insisted is included on the forms.

The Office for National Statistics has so far refused to include a Welsh tick box, saying that if people want to class themselves as Welsh they can tick the box marked "Other" and then write "Welsh" alongside.

This has not proved good enough for protesters in Wales, and there have been growing calls for Welsh people to be given the same status as the Scots when the census is carried out next year.

Council leaders join campaign

Last week, the Welsh Local Government Association called on the Office for National Statistics to revise its plans for next year's census so that the form will include a Welsh tick-box.

The previous week, Plaid Cymru president Ieuan Wyn Jones wrote to Mr Blair seeking a pledge from the government to make changes to the recently published census forms.

"People are appalled that the Office for National Statistics (ONS) is refusing to change its mind on the issue," said Mr Jones.

"I think Tony Blair should intervene and sort this out.

"As there is to be a 'tick box' for the Irish and Scots, people simply cannot understand why there cannot be one for Wales.

"This is grossly discriminatory and unfair."

For 'Welsh' read 'Other'.

The ONS said census legislation for Scotland was devolved to the Scottish Parliament, which had taken the decision to add the Scottish tick box.

For Wales, the matter was decided in London, and the decision was taken not to include a tick box for people to say they were Welsh.

However, in response to the complaints, a spokesman for the ONS said Welsh people could tick the box marked "Other" and then write in that they were Welsh. They would then be counted as Welsh in the census returns.

"If people choose to define their ethnicity as 'Welsh' they can do so via the write-in boxes, an ONS statement read.

"ONS has made it very clear that if people tell us they are Welsh they will be counted as Welsh and has said that it will publish the results.

MP Simon Thomas
MP Simon Thomas is protesting against the situation
The ONS said it was too late to change the boxes for the census, which is due to take place next year.

However, Ieuan Wyn Jones said it would not take much for Parliament to correct the situation.

Last week, the Plaid Cymru MP for Ceredigion, Simon Thomas, wrote to the chief executives of every local authority and all town and community councils in Wales.

He is asking for support to pressurise the government to change the census forms.

Gwynedd council has already described the ONS position as an "insult" to Wales.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

11 Sep 00 | Wales
Welsh equality row over census
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Wales stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Wales stories