Page last updated at 05:50 GMT, Friday, 21 May 2010 06:50 UK

Foster children 'moved too often'

Distressed boy (generic image)
The committee found foster children are moved too often

Concerns have been raised about the frequency with which children in care are being moved around foster carers.

A report into the placement of children in care by the assembly's children and young people committee found one child was moved 11 times in seven years.

Assembly members said money should not be an obstacle to giving children in care the best chance in life.

They added that local authorities should value positive, long-term outcomes over short-term savings.

The committee heard personal evidence from children and young people who had experienced the child placement system.

These vulnerable children must be put at the heart of any decision involving their future
Helen Mary Jones AM

Many paid tribute to the foster carers they had stayed with, but concerns were raised about the amount of times some had been moved.

One young person told the committee he was moved 11 times in seven years.

Chair Helen Mary Jones said: "This is a particular concern to the committee. We heard that since 2006 the number of children who had been placed three or more times within a year had dropped by four per cent.

"While this demonstrates an improvement, the committee doesn't feel it is good enough and the Welsh government must work with local authorities and child welfare organisations to improve that figure."

Legally binding

The AMs' report, following a 10-month inquiry, makes it clear more must be done to give children in care the best possible chance in life.

The committee found that, despite insight gained in working with children, foster carers were excluded from decisions concerning the children in their care.

The report recommends the Welsh assembly government produces legally binding guidance to ensure local authorities listen to children, foster carers and other advocates.

One fostered child told the committee: "I never had a say until I was 16 years old."

Barnardo's Cymru, Children in Wales, the Fostering Network and Action for Children all gave evidence to the inquiry.

They concluded there were plenty of examples of good practice in Wales, but in some instances process and procedure were being put before the best interests of the child.

Ms Jones said: "These vulnerable children must be put at the heart of any decision involving their future. No two children have the same needs.

We're also pleased that the committee has understood the need to encourage local authorities to allow foster carers to make day-to-day parenting decisions...
Freda Lewis, Fostering Network Wales

"By trying to squeeze them to fit into a rigid process we risk doing more harm than good."

The report contains 33 recommendations spanning areas covered from the initial placement process through information sharing and support for children, young people, foster carers and support workers.

Director of Fostering Network Wales, Freda Lewis, said the recommendations could lead to a real improvement in the lives of children and the families that care for them.

She said: "Particularly welcome are the Welsh Assembly Government's commitment to improving fostering services' communication with foster carers, and a recognition that foster carers are professionals within the child care workforce and should be treated as such.

"We're also pleased that the committee has understood the need to encourage local authorities to allow foster carers to make day-to-day parenting decisions for the children they look after, and hope this encouragement actually translates into action ensuring children in care don't continue to miss out on school trips and other childhood activities unnecessarily."

Barnardo's Cymru spokesman said foster carers must be regarded as part of the professional team of people delivering the best placement possible to that child or young person.

He said: "Unfortunately, there is variable experience of this with, all too often, foster carers not being included in vital meetings or included in the sharing of information - despite them often being the people who know the child best."

Print Sponsor

Child convention law consultation
17 Mar 10 |  Wales
Concerns over care home support
15 Feb 10 |  Wales
Changes for children in care
29 Jun 00 |  UK News
Child care reforms 'unworkable'
17 Jul 07 |  Wales
Council may shut children's homes
18 Nov 09 |  South West Wales
Care home children 'stigmatised'
28 Jan 10 |  Scotland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Telegraph The digital disciple - 2 hrs ago Desmond Tutu | It's time to rid the world of nuclear weapons - 5 hrs ago
Scottish Sun Innocent but named as pirate - 16 hrs ago
Financial TimesThe 1980s: when the 1960s came true - 17 hrs ago
Reuters UK RPT-UPDATE 3-UBS tax deal edges closer to parliamentary approval - 22 hrs ago
* May require registration

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2018 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific