[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 1 March, 2005, 16:09 GMT
Greyhound cruelty appeal lost
Mutilated greyhound
Both the greyhound's ears had been cut off
A man who mutilated a greyhound and left it on a mountain to die has had his appeal against conviction dismissed.

Andrew Gough was jailed for six months in December and banned from keeping animals for life after he shot the dog.

The shot left a gaping hole in the animal's skull but failed to kill it.

He then cut off the dog's ears to prevent identification and dumped him, still alive, by a footpath on Fochriw Mountain, near Merthyr Tydfil.

A woman walking her dog on last May discovered the dog Charlie - who also raced under the name Last Hope.

This was an appalling attack on a defenceless animal in a bungled attempt to kill it
Judge Treverton-Jones

The greyhound was whimpering and had to be put down immediately because he was so distressed.

Gough, 28, of Tiryberth, near Caerphilly, appealed on the grounds that the principal witnesses against him were inconsistent in their accounts of what happened.

Cardiff Crown Court heard this week that the prosecution's original case was that Gough, who kept and raced greyhounds for 20 years, had been paid 10 to dispose of the dog after it became lame and could not race any more.

Richard Ace, prosecuting, said owner John Hurley had decided that Charlie should be destroyed and asked trainer Mark Emmett to organise for the dog to be taken to a local farmer to be put down.

Mr Ace said Gough had said he would use a humane killing tool used to dispose of livestock.

Andrew Gough arriving in court
Andrew Gough was jailed for six months

Gough, a former registered kennel hand, denied that he had been asked to put down the animal.

He told the court he had no knowledge of the methods used to put down greyhounds and had never seen a humane killer.

Giving evidence, Gough told the court: "They are trying to stitch me up. They think that I'm dull but I'm not as dull as I look."

Defending, Kate Broadhurst said: "It is simply not possible to say who caused the injuries to the dog and the only person who knows is the person who did it."

After the greyhound was discovered, a local animal welfare group issued posters appealing for information and Mr Emmett confronted Gough.

Mr Emmett told the court that Gough had insisted he had disposed of the dog humanely.

Judge Treverton-Jones rejected Gough's appeal, saying: "This was an appalling attack on a defenceless animal in a bungled attempt to kill it."

He also dismissed an appeal against Gough's sentence and ban on keeping animals.

"We can't conceive of a very much worse case of animal cruelty than this."

The judge rejected a prosecution application for more than 2,000 costs and, "as a small act of mercy", ordered Gough to pay 250.

Jail and life ban for dog cruelty
22 Dec 04 |  South East Wales
Man guilty of mutilating dog
22 Nov 04 |  South East Wales
Man denies greyhound mutilation
23 Aug 04 |  South East Wales
Three questioned over greyhound
14 May 04 |  South East Wales
Greyhound's ears 'cut off'
07 May 04 |  Wales

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific