BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  UK: Wales
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Thursday, 14 February, 2002, 12:34 GMT
Hart's architect row embarrassment
Site of new Assembly building
The site is currently a fenced-off hole in the ground
The Welsh Assembly's finance minister has described a 432,000 legal dispute with architect Lord Rogers over a new debating chamber as "embarrassing".

The assembly administration was ordered to pay the cash in a special fast-track adjudication - a counter claim by the administration for almost 7m was turned down.

Richard Rogers
Lord Rogers complained over unpaid fees
Lord Rogers' company, the Richard Rogers Partnership (RRP), was sacked from the project in July 2001 because of concerns over escalating costs.

But Lord Rogers brought an action against the assembly, saying it owed his company in unpaid fees.

Finance Minister Edwina Hart told AMs Lord Rogers had claimed 530,000, but the figure was reduced by an adjudicator.

Ms Hart admitted the matter was embarassing, but insisted the decision to sack him was right.

Ms Hart told the assembly that Lord Rogers had "significantly underestimated the cost of the building".

"He was not found to be negligent," she added.

"Although he effectively got it wrong, the assembly is not due any damages or repayment of fees."

Finance Minister Edwina Hart
Finance Minister Edwina Hart
The assembly also claimed it had been misled over the terms of the contract, and had incurred serious costs as a result.

Although the judgement in the case accepted Lord Rogers had underestimated the costs, it felt this was not enough for the assembly to withhold fees.

In her statement, Ms Hart also said she was making a statement about the settlement after details were leaked to the press.

She hoped the matter was now closed, and that "the right professionals" would now take over the project.

Ms Hart also commented that such settlements were "quite normal in the construction industry."

'Major embarrassment'

Normal or not, the news is the latest development in a story which has unfolded over the last four years.

In 1998, RRP had agreed to build the Cardiff Bay debating chamber for 27m but costs subsequently rose to an estimated 37m to 41m.

The saga has been labelled a "major embarrassment" by former Welsh Secretary Ron Davies and Plaid Cymru leader Ieuan Wyn Jones.

Ron Davies
Former Welsh Secretary Ron Davies
Mr Jones also criticised the leadership of First Minister Rhodri Morgan on the issue.

The project has now been put out to tender, and Lord Rogers has teamed up with a construction group in a bid to win back the contract.

The RRP's design now has the backing of the housing, property and construction firm Taylor Woodrow.

Lord Rogers has now pledged to build the new chamber for 13m.

The man behind the Pompidou Centre in Paris and the ill-fated Millennium Dome in London has said the assembly HQ was "one of the best buildings we have ever designed".

But there have been calls for the chamber project to be scrapped and the money to be spent on a new children's hospital instead.

Completion of the building is now scheduled for the second quarter of 2004.

Plaid Cymru leader, Ieuan Wyn Jones
"This information has come out through a leak and should have been made available to all Assembly Members."
BBC Wales's Simon Morris
"Edwina Hart was unapologetic this morning"
Welsh Assembly Chamber Row

Key stories




Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Wales stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Wales stories