BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: UK: Wales
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Tuesday, 25 September, 2001, 13:43 GMT 14:43 UK
Game show cough man baffled by row
Chris Tarrant
The show's producers are examining the programme tapes
A contestant on TV quiz Who Wants To Be A Millionaire? has said it would have been virtually impossible for 1m winner Charles Ingram to have cheated.

Major Ingram's 1m win was edited out of Saturday's programme while police investigate claims he may have been aided by coded coughing in the audience.

But college lecturer Tecwen Whittock said he and several other audience members had innocently coughed during the major's 1m round.
Tecwen Whittock, Millionaire? contestant
Tecwen Whittock: 'Would not have aided another contestant'

Mr Whittock said it would have been hard to differentiate between different coughs.

Major Ingrams has denied cheating and threatened legal action against production company Celador, who have yet to pay out his 1m prize.

The police were called into investigate the programme tapes after producers feared Major Ingram may have received a signal from the audience.

Major Ingram, 38, became only the third person in the show's history to scoop the 1m prize, but his win has been marred by the subsequent claims.

Mr Whittock, 51, from Whitchurch, Cardiff, said he had coughed naturally and the noise could not have had anything to do with the alleged controversy surrounding the jackpot win.

Mr Whittock, from Whitchurch, Cardiff, said his cough was brought on by the cold studio and he added a number of audience members had been coughing during filming.

"I certainly wasn't trying to help him. I wasn't in any of the contestants' interests to help him

Tecwen Whittock, Millionaire? contestant

Mr Whittock said none of the contestants waiting in the audience had any interest in helping someone win the big prize.

"Yes, I did cough while the major was in the hot seat - but many other people in the studio did too," said the Pontypridd College lecturer.

"There were 200 people in there and it was quite cold. I heard many people coughing and can't believe the major could have been helped in such a way."

He added: "I certainly wasn't trying to help him. It wasn't in any of the contestants' interests to help him - we wanted him out so we could have our go."

Mr Whittock, head of Pontypridd College Business School, later went on to win just 1,000 on the show.
Major Charles Ingram is angered by the claims
Major Charles Ingram is angered by the claims

The lecturer said he could not understand the intense speculation over "coughing clues".

"The first I knew something was wrong was when the producers called to say my episode had been brought forward.

"Everything seemed fine at the time - Chris Tarrant was delighted he had won the 1m and we all clapped and cheered for him.

"It would have been extremely difficult for him to distinguish his accomplice from all the different people coughing in the audience.

"But if what is being said is proved he should not be paid the prize because cheating is wrong."

The UK's two previous Millionaire? jackpot winners are Judith Keppel and David Edwards.

Major Charles Ingram
speaking at a press conference
See also:

12 Sep 01 | TV and Radio
Army officer 'is next Millionaire'
20 Nov 00 | Entertainment
Questions on the path to 1m
21 Nov 00 | Entertainment
Millionaire moments
03 Nov 00 | Entertainment
Millionaire contestant wins 500,000
25 Sep 01 | TV and Radio
Millionaire winner sues quiz show
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Wales stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Wales stories