Page last updated at 13:10 GMT, Wednesday, 17 December 2008

Bid to replace short prison terms

Ministers are seeking more effective short-term punishments

Prison sentences of six months or less are to be discouraged, Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill has said.

Speaking during a visit to Polmont Young Offenders Institute, Mr MacAskill said the government wanted "tough" community orders used instead.

He said a new Community Payback Sentence would see offenders agree to unpaid work before they left court.

The measures will form part of a bill aimed at tackling prison overcrowding and high levels of reoffending.

Mr MacAskill said the unpaid community work would start within a week of a court appearance and finish inside six months.

He said: "I won't sit back and see low-risk offenders on short sentences get free bed and board when they could be paying back to the communities they harm.

"The facts speak for themselves - 58% of offenders who get a Community Service Order have kept a clean record after two years.

"This compares with only 26% of those released from prison sentences of six months or less."

They have basically established a criminals' charter where offenders will know they have a good chance of dodging jail even though they have committed sometimes serious crimes
Richard Baker MSP
Mr MacAskill said the move would help build confidence in community sentences and make them immediate and of benefit to the communities involved.

Judges should not impose a custodial sentence of six months or less unless they feel there is no other option, under the terms of the forthcoming Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Bill.

Judges are also to be allowed to hold review hearings to check progress of community sentences, under the new plans.

Tagging is also to be introduced for judges considering breach of bail, extending its use from things such as home detention curfews at the end of prisoners' sentence.

A Scottish Sentencing Council is also to be set up to bring greater "consistency and transparency" to the sentencing process.

It comes after former First Minister Henry McLeish's Prisons Commission report which was published earlier this year and called for fewer criminals being jailed and community sentencing to be toughened up.

'Independent judiciary'

There are 7,770 prisoners in Scottish jails at present, according to figures from the Scottish Prison Service, with a further 396 on home detention curfew (HDC).

Ministers claim this is among the highest levels in Europe while offending rates are at a record low.

Labour claimed the proposals would leave some sex offenders, knife criminals and people guilty of serious assault more likely to "dodge" jail.

Party justice spokesman Richard Baker said: "The public will be quite rightly outraged at this move today by the SNP.

Polmont YOI
Mr MacAskill was speaking during a visit to Polmont YOI

"They have basically established a criminals' charter where offenders will know they have a good chance of dodging jail even though they have committed sometimes serious crimes."

Tory justice spokesman Bill Aitken said the plans will end in disaster.

"From looking at these proposals there is no longer any doubt - the SNP is hell-bent on creating a soft-touch Scotland and the plans outlined in today's response are nothing more than a recipe for disaster," he said.

"Not only is the Scottish Government intent on curbing the power of what is supposedly an independent judiciary, but it is actively moving away from considering prison as a valid option for offenders, which is unacceptable."

But Liberal Democrat justice spokesman Robert Brown said the move would seek more effective means to cut reoffending rates.

Mr Brown said: "It's not about easing prison overcrowding, although that's a helpful side-product, it's about having something that's more effective in terms of stopping people reoffending."

The MSP said community sentences led to a far lower reoffending rate in the realm of 45%.

He added: "This has got to work in practical terms and people do have to have confidence in the community that it's going to be effective and successful."

Print Sponsor

Judges condemn sentence guidance
12 Dec 08 |  Scotland
Prison numbers 'must be tackled'
01 Jul 08 |  Scotland
Short jail sentences 'pointless'
27 May 08 |  Scotland
Ministers propose court reforms
31 Jan 08 |  Scotland
Sentencing plan 'is tough enough'
13 Nov 06 |  Scotland


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2020 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific