BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 18 March 2008, 03:52 GMT
Minister in soldier inquests plea
Private Jason Smith
A second inquest is to be held into Pte Smith's death
Defence Secretary Des Browne has asked that strongly-worded criticisms of the Ministry of Defence be outlawed from inquests on soldiers.

The plea came in a test case relating to Scottish soldier Pte Jason Smith, 32, who died of heatstroke in Iraq.

A first inquest said his death was due to a "serious failure" in not noting the difficulty he had with the climate.

Mr Browne's legal representative said the phrase "serious failure" could be seen as deciding civil liability.

Pte Smith, from Roxburghshire, fell ill in temperatures of 60C (140F) in August 2003 at the Al Amara stadium, southern Iraq.

The Territorial Army recruit, who was attached to the 1st Battalion the King's Own Scottish Borderers (KOSB), collapsed at an abandoned stadium, where his unit was stationed.

Soldier's mother

He had previously complained about feeling ill.

At an inquest in November 2006, Oxfordshire's assistant deputy coroner, Andrew Walker, concluded that the soldier's death was "caused by a serious failure to recognise and take appropriate steps to address the difficulty that he had in adjusting to the climate".

The coroner said Pte Smith's difficulty in acclimatising to the heat should have been recognised.

Des Browne
Defence Secretary Des Browne made his plea at a test hearing

However, on Monday the wording of his verdict came under attack at the High Court in London before Mr Justice Collins.

Sarah Moore, appearing for the defence secretary, said the coroner should not have made reference to a "serious failure" to take appropriate steps.

She argued that the phrase could be seen as deciding civil liability and that could not be allowed under Rule 42 of the 1984 Coroners' Rules.

Lawyers acting for the late soldier's mother, Catherine Smith, argued that Mr Browne's legal challenge was "misconceived".

The judge was told the issue remained important as a new inquest was to be held into Pte Smith's death because of flaws in the original hearing.

Ms Moore said "a matter of general importance" had been raised because the phrase "serious failing" was cropping up on a regular basis in inquests into Iraqi military deaths.

Pte Smith's family are also making submissions to the court over the scope of the new inquest and asking the judge to order full disclosure of MoD documents, except those covered by public interest immunity.

The three-day judicial review will decide the remit of the new inquest.

A bereaved father criticises the move

Army inquiry criticised by family
03 May 07 |  South of Scotland
Heat vests for Iraq troops tested
19 Mar 07 |  South of Scotland
Army blamed for Iraq heat death
10 Nov 06 |  South of Scotland
Families 'sent soldiers supplies'
09 Nov 06 |  South of Scotland
Soldiers collapsed daily - claim
08 Nov 06 |  South of Scotland
'Hellhole' claim heard at inquest
07 Nov 06 |  South of Scotland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific