BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK: Scotland
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

BBC Scotland Political editor Brian Taylor reports
"Rural Affairs Minister Ross Finnie insisted the validity of the test would not be affected"
 real 28k

Tuesday, 20 June, 2000, 13:40 GMT 14:40 UK
Flaw discovered in GM crop trial
Oilseed rape
Advanta has been at centre of contamination row
Conventional crops planted as part of an experiment to test the impact of GM crops have been revealed as being part of a GM contaminated batch of seed.

The "control" group at Daviot, in Aberdeenshire, has been found to have been planted with contaminated material from Advanta.

Advanta was recently at the centre of a row over the contamination of conventional seed.

The Scottish Executive said the latest discovery would have no impact on the final result of the trial.

Ross Finnie speaks in the Scottish Parliament
Ross Finnie: Consulted advisers
Rural Affairs Minister Ross Finnie also insisted there was no risk to public health.

He stressed the trial oilseed rape would be destroyed upon completion of the research and would not be marketed. It would not enter the human or animal food chain.

Mr Finnie said he had consulted scientific advisers on whether action was needed.

"As a result of these extensive consultations, I am satisfied that the validity of the trial has not been compromised and our scientific advisers have confirmed there are no implications for the safety of the surrounding environment," he said.

"The strict conditions under which these trials are taking place mean that this site will be carefully and rigorously monitored."

He went on: "The contamination of the control crop with a GM variety does not affect the scientific merit of the trial.

'No change of plan'

"I must stress that the GM crop itself is not being assessed in these trials - it has been subjected to and passed numerous safety checks before it could be grown as part of the trial.

"The purpose of the farm trials is to assess the possible impact on the environment of growing a GM crop in commercial conditions and, in particular, using the herbicides necessary to give the GM plant its 'advantage'."

But the Scottish National Party called on the executive to end the GM venture.

Rural Affairs spokesman, Alasdair Morgan MSP, said: "This field trial has descended into a complete and utter farce.

"There is absolutely no point in proceeding with these tests now that it has been revealed that both sets of oilseed rape planted on the farm are GM."

Robin Harper
Robin Harper: "Crop must be pulled up"
Scottish Green Party MSP, Robin Harper, said: "If the executive wants to get public opinion back on their side they have no option but to order the pulling up of this crop.

"Failure to do so will simply confirm the public in their growing perception that this government and their Scottish Executive is still following a policy of cover up, delay secrecy and obfuscation in relation to GM."

The farmer conducting the Aberdeenshire trial said the revelations would not change her plans.

Shirley Harrison told BBC Scotland the level of contamination was so small, the trial would continue as agreed and would have no impact on the final results.

Information about the control plot contamination came to light after the executive sought further details on where the Advanta seed had been planted.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

09 Jun 00 | Scotland
'No harm' from GM crops
23 May 00 | UK Politics
Protest over GM blunder
01 Jun 00 | Scotland
Al-Fayed anger in GM seed row
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Scotland stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Scotland stories