Page last updated at 19:06 GMT, Sunday, 15 March 2009

Night shifts spark cancer pay-out

By Kenneth Macdonald
BBC Scotland Special Correspondent

Ulla Mahnkopf: 'When I stopped flying it was like coming out of'

The Danish government has begun paying compensation to women who have developed breast cancer after long spells working nights.

It follows a ruling by a United Nations agency that night shifts probably increase the risk of developing cancer.

BBC Radio Scotland's The Investigation has been hearing from experts and union leaders in Scotland who said the UK government should be doing more to tackle the dangers.

For years there has been growing evidence that night shifts are bad for you.

Among the symptoms: disturbed sleep, fatigue, digestive problems and a greater risk of accidents at work.

But these are the first government payments to women who have developed breast cancer after long spells on the night shift.

Ulla Mahnkopf is one of those who has been compensated.

Long hours

She spent 30 years as a flight attendant for the big Scandinavian airline SAS.

Long hours and disturbed working patterns came with the territory.

Then she developed breast cancer.

"It was awful telling my kids that, telling them what we were facing," she told me.

"It's not just the surgery but all the thoughts - do I survive this? I had bilateral cancer so not just one breast, two breasts."

At first she did not make the connection between her cancer and night working.

She said: "I had no idea.

"But when you think back now I can see that when I stopped flying it was like coming out of a shell, I had been living in there because of jet lag and I can see now I had a totally different life."

The level of evidence is really no different than it might be for an industrial chemical
Dr Vincent Cogliano
So far almost 40 Danish women have won compensation.

Not every case was successful: women who had a family history of breast cancer were among the ones whose claims were rejected.

The Danish authorities acted following a finding by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), an arm of the UN's World Health Organisation.

The IARC studies and ranks cancer risks.

Category One risks are known carcinogens such as asbestos. Night working now sits just one rung below that: a probable cause of cancer.

Dr Vincent Cogliano of the IARC said they reached their conclusion after looking at a wide number of studies of both humans and animals.

One of the reports, published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute, showed a 36% greater risk of breast cancer for women who had worked night shifts for more than 30 years, compared with women who had never worked nights.

concentric circles showing breast cancer risk

He said there was evidence to support the hypothesis that alterations in sleep patterns could suppress the production of melatonin in the body.

"Melatonin has some beneficial effects in preventing some of the steps leading to cancer," he said.

"The level of evidence is really no different than it might be for an industrial chemical."

Here in the UK unions estimate about 20% of the national workforce is involved in night shifts.

Margaret Ann Hancock from Edinburgh was like many parents who take on the night shift: she needed the extra money and had a young family to care for.

When she started work at the former Leith Hospital in the 1980s, her shift pattern allowed her to take her three children to nursery when she got home, sleeping just a few hours before picking them up again.

At the time, she said, tiredness and disrupted meals seemed a reasonable price to pay: "I felt like I battled time continually.

"There's only so much you can get done in a day.

"And because I did split nights, I often wasn't sleeping until the following day.

Margaret Ann Hancock
Margaret Ann Hancock worked night shifts with three children at nursery

"My sleeping patterns, even now, my eating patterns - that side of it is still with me."

It was during her time at Leith hospital that she developed breast cancer, undergoing a lumpectomy, radium treatment and chemotherapy.

At the time, she said she would never have dreamt that there could have been a connection between her disease and her night work.

But now that she knows it is a possibility, as a breast cancer survivor, she has a clear message for other women who may find themselves in her position: "You should have a choice whether or not to do nights.

"If I knew then what I know would be better, if there is an alternative.

"Because if it's risking your health, there's nothing worth that."

Professor Andrew Watterson, an occupational health specialist at Stirling University, said we are far behind Scandinavia in recognising the dangers.

"I think we can say there is a big public health problem here," he said.

"The evidence has been good over a long period of time about cardiovascular disease and night work, gastro-intestinal problems and nights.

"Work indicates there may be risks in terms of low birth-weight babies and longer pregnancies for women.

"We don't tend to identify the damage being done where shift working is prevalent and I think that's an error. The damage is there but we don't see it and we don't count it."

If your nights are busy, it can be fine but you lose your social life
Steve G, Reading

At the Health and Safety Executive, chief medical officer Dr John Osmond said they were aware of the debate and have commissioned their own research.

"The HSE has been very on the ball in this area and has commissioned a very eminent epidemiologist to examine the risk of working at night and whether there is any link to breast cancer. This report will be completed in 2011."

But assistant general secretary of the Scottish TUC, Ian Tasker, thinks the UK is lagging behind.

He fears workers may be missing out on health checks to which they are entitled under the existing law.

Greater awareness

"I don't think we have enough evidence to say they're not," he said.

"But we have a feeling that perhaps employers are taking the opportunity to ensure these health checks are not carried out or, if they are, it's very much a tick-box approach to it."

In the meantime unions are calling for a greater awareness of the dangers of night shifts.

But for some workers, such as Ulla Mahnkopf, that is already too late.

She said she would have given up her job if she had known the dangers.

"I wouldn't have been flying for that many years, definitely not. Because it's cancer you can die from. So I would like to stay alive."

The Investigation was broadcast on BBC Radio Scotland at 0900 GMT on Monday.

Print Sponsor


Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2020 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific