[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Friday, 31 August 2007, 15:32 GMT 16:32 UK
Cosla calls for vote separation
Ballot papers, May 2007
Voter confusion has been blamed for the number of spoiled papers
Local authority leaders have called for future council elections to be held on a different day from the vote for the Scottish Parliament.

More than 140,000 ballots were spoiled on 3 May when both votes were held.

Scottish council umbrella group Cosla criticised ministers for ignoring warnings that their ballot arrangements risked electoral chaos.

Finance Secretary John Swinney said he was keen in principle to take the proposal forward.

Cosla officials believe running council elections at the same time as the Holyrood election, involving first-past-the-post and two separate proportional representation systems, was directly responsible for voter confusion and the large number of spoiled papers.

There is a need to ensure local authorities get the opportunity to speak to the electorate on local issues without the noise of a national election
John Swinney
Finance Secretary

At a meeting they also noted that the council elections were almost completely overshadowed in the media.

Therefore they believe the elections should be separated even though they recognise the extra cost involved.

Cosla president Pat Watters said: "The feeling at the meeting was to have a five-year term for councils with the next local government elections being in 2012.

"Discussion also focussed on mid-term in relation to the Parliament elections being the best time for local government elections and indeed perhaps we should look at two five-year terms for a transition to get to this point and then revert to four-year terms."

Local democracy

Mr Swinney said: "Cosla's report on decoupling the Scottish Parliament and local authority elections is very helpful and I am keen in principle to take forward the suggestion they have made.

"There is a need to ensure local authorities get the opportunity to speak to the electorate on local issues without the noise of a national election.

"I will take forward early discussions with Cosla to examine the practical issues involved in this proposal before going back to parliament and parliamentary committees for further consideration.

John Swinney
John Swinney said he liked the proposals in principle

"We cannot pre-empt the outcome of the current investigation into this year's election, however, the points raised by Cosla are an important contribution to the ongoing discussion on the future arrangements of elections in Scotland."

Scottish Conservative MSP Gavin Brown said: "We have been constant critics of the decision to hold these two important elections on the same day.

"The arguments in favour of local democracy have been well rehearsed. The events of May 3rd have only added fresh ammunition to the compelling case for de-coupling."

He said the Scottish Tories would be re-submitting a member's bill on the issue.

"I am encouraged by John Swinney's comments today and will seek an early meeting with him to discuss the best way forward," he added.

"If local democracy is to flourish and be truly accountable, then it must have its own day in the spotlight."

A Green Party spokesman said: "We agree that it makes sense to hold the ballots separately but the conclusion that this was the main reason for the number of spoilt papers is dubious considering the extent of concern over the Holyrood ballot paper design.

"Such conclusions cannot be reached till we see the result of the election review."

Inquiry into vote fiasco delayed
26 Jul 07 |  Scotland
Election group criticises ballots
05 May 07 |  Scotland
Rejected votes more than thought
09 May 07 |  Scotland
Expert to head elections review
14 May 07 |  Scotland
Clue over voter ballot confusion
15 May 07 |  Scotland
Ballot paper report at-a-glance
23 Jun 07 |  Scotland


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific